WhyNot?

SuperWiki

Category: Internet
Responses: 5 (2 in support, 2 neutral, 1 in opposition)
Number of views: 1872
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Average AverageYour Rating:

------from an email to the AP-----------

Hello Associated Press! (and a copy to others I think would be interested)

I am looking for a partner to develop a new concept in free, open source Internet collaboration software. I call it Superwiki. It would have a fantastic application for news gathering and production. Please let me explain...

My motive is only to see this technology developed as fast as possible, as I believe it represents a major breakthrough for humanity as a much improved tool for collaborating and sharing ideas.

A wiki is a popular type of collaborative website where readers can edit and add pages, contributing in an anarchic fashion. A Superwiki improves upon wikis by allowing professional writers to maintain editorial control, coherent organization and style. If we apply a Superwiki to news reporting, every consumer of news also becomes a potential participant in its creation and improvement. With widespread input from readers, news stories can quickly evolve, closely following events and becoming ever more balanced and accurate.

When a reader of a Superwiki news story realizes that he/she has a critical piece of missing information, they can quickly add it to the story. The contribution shows up immediately in an unofficial wiki version of the story, but takes a short time to be incorporated into the certified AP version (if it even makes the cut). In the 'news room,' the journalist who is leading the story and his/her team filter reader contributions and assimilate them into the story (or follow up on new leads) as they see fit.

We track regular contributors so that they build reputations and can earn places as reader-stringers. They can be compensated based on the volume and quality of their contributions.

If the AP team discards a certain perspective from contributors (or otherwise adds bias to a story), the reader contributors have the freedom to continue to develop their own (non-AP) version of the story, editing on the website itself. This ability to "fork" a story (i.e. start a new version) is an important part of the Superwiki system, allowing unverified or dissenting views to develop. Occasionally, a fork will prove itself to be true. When this happens, the AP journalist has the freedom to incorporate the newly verified information into the official AP version of the story. This powerful check and balance is enabled by requiring reader contributions to be released completely into the Public Domain. Contributors choose to contribute in the Public Domain and the AP chooses to yield enough so that readers are free to make derivative works of stories (the forks) on the same Superwiki website.

How could this work? The AP can maintain a reputation for generating a flow of high quality, factual, complete, concise, balanced and well written information, whether or not they retain any copyright protection on the information. The AP retains full editorial control for the certified versions of their evolving stories, but now they have a system where the entire world becomes a resource to help build and improve news stories.

Superwiki tames the chaotic tendencies of wikis, while retaining the benefits of massive collaboration. The potential application to create factual, unbiased, evolving news stories can not be ignored. I hope you will agree to investigate this further and consider working to develop Superwiki. I would be happy to help in any way I can.

More information on Superwiki:http://betterdifferent.com/software/superwiki

---

NATE JOHNSON

858-824-9003, n_johnson@yahoo.com, 7415 Charmant Drive #2512, San Diego CA, 92122, USA

PASSION

Finding better ways to communicate, collaborate and have fun.

INNOVATION

2004 Developed a proposal to use a wiki to improve Home Depot internal communication.

2003 Launched betterdifferent.com to promote free information sharing and related ideas.

2002 Built an all-digital TV studio with redundant storage and live call-in for only $80K.

1998-00 Founded and ran partypeople.org, reporting on major party events worldwide.

1998 Set-up a website to keep families informed during their unit's deployment to Bosnia.

1997 Used desktop publishing to disseminate classified military intelligence in the field.

1994-96 Produced and developed two multimedia CD-ROMs as yearbook supplements.

EDUCATION

BSEE, Electrical and Computer Engineering, West Point, NY 1996

LEADERSHIP

1 year, Home Depot's Store Leadership Program, training to be a store manager 03-04

- directed nationwide market research, uncovering insights that changed strategy

- connected directly with customers to truly understand their perspective and needs

6 years, US Army Intelligence Officer (Captain), Basic and Advanced Officer Training 96-03

- trained and experienced in the ultimate form of strategy and competitor analysis,regularly reporting and presenting to senior leaders

- executive officer for 100+ NATO intelligence staff (14 countries represented)

Expert communicator

- known for explaining technology, advocating change and building team buy-in

Problem-solver

- skilled at identifying root causes and capitalizing on opportunities for improvement

TECHNICAL EXPERTISE

Deep knowledge of "digital convergence" technologies:

- PC hardware, software, multimedia, audio/video/TV, data networking and storage

- open source software, including license issues, operating systems and web technologyFast self-learner, constantly expanding skills

LIFE EXPERIENCES

Global perspective from extensive travel (28 countries) and military assignments.

Basic Spanish and some German (lived in Germany 3 years).

The Learning Channel "The Makeover Story" reality TV, "Fashion Builders" episode

Private Pilot

Mensa

GOALS

1. Superwiki. Develop a new type of wiki website for Internet and intranet use that bridges the gap between open access wiki's and closed access traditional websites, allowing readers to directly contribute changes but leaving editorial control in the hands of an author who "directs" the collaborative work. Top benefits: with broad reader input, current events, news stories and reference resources can evolve to be factual, complete, balanced and unbiased. A collaborative intranet can break down communication barriers, resulting in educated decision-making at all levels and inspiring innovation and teamwork.

2. Information Sharing. Enable widespread sharing of software, written works, music, film, etc. by providing an alternative to information ownership and copyright law. With an easy way to collect voluntary tips from consumers via the Internet, creators / artists can choose to release their work without copyright restrictions. Top benefits: artists can embrace file sharing, as the more people that experience their work and enjoy it, the more tips they will receive. Information will be free to evolve to its most useful form. More music and TV shows can be available on-demand on the Internet.

3. Universal Drive. Create an Internet file system that is fully shared (non-private information only), fully distributed (each user's machine participates), redundant and non-destructive (nothing is deleted, only incremental changes are saved). Eventually people can choose free operating systems and software running directly off this "universal drive." Top benefits: dependable and efficient global storage, access to your stuff from anywhere, faster evolving software and saving a complete digital history for future historians.

PERFECT JOBS

1. New Technology Research and Development Director, web-based collaboration, micropayment "tips," or Internet storage services

2. Customer Intelligence / Market Research Manager, consumer electronics or personal computer company

3. Chief Technology Officer, start-up or small business seeking cost savings and competitive advantage through transparency and open source methods

4. IT Consultant, firm that balances the benefits of both proprietary and open source software

Required:

- environment conducive to experimenting with new ways of doing things

- responsibilities that include following and analyzing technology developments for use insolving real world business problems

- leadership position with authority to lead change

Preferred:

- Multinational company with a global world view

- San Diego, California, USA area

n8johnson, Mar 06 2004

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Other ideas in category (Internet):

My Personal Library on Amazon (8 votes) Strong
Reverse Ebay: Want to buy XYZ (74 votes) Very strong
Require Porn sites to be .sex (110 votes) Very strong
New Travel Search Idea (8 votes) Strong
further expansion of whynot (2 votes) Average
Google Porn (15 votes) Average
Microsoft .net 3.5 Error Solve (1 votes) Average
Google Tune (2 votes) Average
Multiple Home Pages (3 votes) Average
Auto send email on inactivity (0 votes) Very weak
Drag-n-Drop Files to Webpage (7 votes) Strong
Reverse Ebay (15 votes) Very strong
New Google filter (4 votes) Average
Tech Spec Plugins (2 votes) Average
Second-hand Mkt. - Gift Cards (9 votes) Average
WhyNot Delete Function (3 votes) Average
Filter PPC ads by language (1 votes) Average
Browser improvement (1 votes) Average
Save with meta tags (2 votes) Average
SuperWiki (5 votes) Average
advertisement web site (1 votes) Average
Scheduled outgoing gmails (3 votes) Average
Audio Websites (5 votes) Average
5kbps Local Wifi Node (1 votes) Average
Wikipedia for Original Content (1 votes) Average
Mapquest for Walkers (14 votes) Very strong
Web directions with landmarks (2 votes) Average
NerdMakeover.com (3 votes) Average
P2P over HTTPS - ISP nightmare (4 votes) Average
AgedAdvice.com (2 votes) Average
Integrate Phone and email! (1 votes) Average
RestyleMe.com (2 votes) Average
Better Search Results (5 votes) Average
Healing Viruses (2 votes) Average
face recognition search engine (2 votes) Average
Ability to Recall E-mail (5 votes) Average
automatic blog cross-posting (1 votes) Average
Directions Route Options (6 votes) Strong
GPS from Photosynth or similar (2 votes) Average
Online Biography project (1 votes) Average
IOUs on Friendster, MySpace... (3 votes) Average
Internet pornography solution. (15 votes) Very weak
Get rid of the WWW prefix (18 votes) Weak
Extra Storage Space (2 votes) Average
Animated Emoticons at Why Not (2 votes) Average
Malleable Forums (3 votes) Average
Buyers pay reverse auction fee (2 votes) Average
Map-Based Travel Guide (4 votes) Average
Version Grabbing (1 votes) Average
A truly free market (1 votes) Average
Testimonial Website for an EX (3 votes) Average
Better than outdated magazines (2 votes) Average
Electronic Signatures (4 votes) Average
Local Online Service Auctions (2 votes) Average
Porno Viewing Time Counter (4 votes) Average
Blog-ring post aggregator (3 votes) Average
freeBay (5 votes) Average
Tracking trains like flights (3 votes) Average
Cell connect (3 votes) Average
Tagging Audio (3 votes) Average
Kidnapping Fedex Shipments (3 votes) Average
Co-operative Broadband (4 votes) Average
Underline anchors (2 votes) Average
Ebay Eye (2 votes) Average
An Open Search engine (2 votes) Average
Grab a shovel (2 votes) Average
Mailing Lists for Any Website (0 votes) Very weak
Online Polling (2 votes) Average
One User Name & Password (3 votes) Average
Good Spam (12 votes) Very strong
Innovative Olympics (6 votes) Average
Data manager (password, addres (2 votes) Average
Why Not Navigation? (1 votes) Average
Intuitive domain name system (4 votes) Average
Ex/Import util. for del.icio.u (2 votes) Average
Postal Address Management (3 votes) Average
Fare Reduction Alert (1 votes) Average
Graphical Evolution (4 votes) Average
mozilla printability detection (2 votes) Average
Reading long texts in browser (3 votes) Average
Anon. Net Access (6 votes) Average
Smarter mail speller (3 votes) Average
Recursive Trackback (3 votes) Weak
Hypefilter for news feeds (2 votes) Average
Window on the World website (2 votes) Average
Audio Email (4 votes) Average
Search-in-store (2 votes) Average
Zip Codes on Location Websites (2 votes) Average
Open Packets (2 votes) Average
Date Code Web Pages (4 votes) Average
Rebay (3 votes) Average
keyboard (5 votes) Average
ISHN Numbers (1 votes) Average
Digital Pictures Archiving (1 votes) Average
More security level groups (1 votes) Average
Commity Wi-Fi meets GRID (2 votes) Average
On holiday (2 votes) Average
A Letters To The Editor site (2 votes) Average
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

This seems an interesting idea but the volume of contributions from random sources would, it seems to me, to create a chaos of unvalidated information. The "super" concept would add editorial discipline to the mix, but isn't this merely a step back to the normal pruning that the regular news services impose? And who could tell what kinds of general points of view might be imposed to eliminate or enforce aspects of the story in a particular and perhaps prejudiced direction?

sand, Mar 07 2004

Take it to an existing Wiki community (MediaWiki, etc.)

dumllama, Jul 04 2005

Good idea. Within the www.spirilogic.com group we have initiated a concept called WiMantic. We read your article and decided to add the alias 'SuperWiki'. The WiMantic concept provides for your editorial control concept, and more...

The concept has been posted at: http://www.whynot.net/ideas/1146

Progress / status is posted at: http://www.spirilogic.com/03-WiMantic/02-WiMantic%20Event%20Page/01-%20WiMantic%20Events.html

Feel free to contact us. Interesting to see that after 'all these years' your requirements haven't been fullfilled yet!

Regards,Iwanjka

Iwanjka, Mar 01 2009

Copyright © Barry Nalebuff & Ian Ayres