WhyNot?

Half-size Cigarettes?

Category: Questions
Responses: 19 (16 in support, 0 neutral, 3 in opposition)
Number of views: 4880
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Very strong Very strongYour Rating:

Far too many times have I heard smokers complaining about the inconveniently long length of the average cigarette - not only do many smokers often not have the time to finish a cigarette, many times they don't even want to finish it - but they do as they don't want to 'waste' the rest.

So aside from the insidious possibility that tobacco companies want smokers to force themselves to further damage their lungs, why isn't there a company out there making shorter cigarettes? If a company were to manufacture half-size cigarettes (perhaps with double the number of them per pack), they could probably charge more per pack and still sell at a quick pace. Plus, since I don't get the impression smokers smoke less frequently due to the length of their cigarettes, the end result of the current length of cigarette is simply more secondhand smoke for everyone else - manufacturing shorter cigarettes as a public service?

lokani24, Apr 16 2004

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Other ideas in category (Questions):

Comments for negative votes (9 votes) Average
Improbable Motion (1 votes) Average
Perpetual motion (3 votes) Average
Why can't you tickle yourself? (2 votes) Average
self powered generator (5 votes) Average
Half-size Cigarettes? (19 votes) Very strong
hydrogen from lightning (3 votes) Average
Public School Fundraising (4 votes) Average
Energy of water (1 votes) Average
Encouraging Generosity (3 votes) Average
Equity sharing for renters (6 votes) Weak
use Bluetooth to read RFID tag (2 votes) Average
day of 100,000 seconds (1 votes) Average
Aircraft tires (2 votes) Average
Nicotine Inhaler (2 votes) Average
Black hole point of view (2 votes) Average
nuclear energy (3 votes) Weak
How to convert force to motion (4 votes) Average
ENERGY PRODUCTION (5 votes) Weak
Why don't they feel my pain? (1 votes) Average
Some ideas+ for Traffic (1 votes) Average
Fastest Man-Made Object (1 votes) Average
Space-Orbital Transfer (3 votes) Average
Fun Questions (3 votes) Average
Where are the stars? (4 votes) Average
I can C clearly now..or can I? (1 votes) Average
What happened to StarLite? (2 votes) Average
More Money (2 votes) Average
Curiousity (2 votes) Average
Keys order on key board (3 votes) Average
Using Why Not Ideas (9 votes) Strong
Dreams- A reality (1 votes) Average
Degree of agreement (1 votes) Average
Neutral vote (5 votes) Average
Prevent getting "plowed in"? (1 votes) Average
What's that smell? (3 votes) Average
Difference?? (4 votes) Average
Loose to Gain? (2 votes) Average
What am I missing? (2 votes) Average
Fragile (1 votes) Average
How to Increase Organ Donation (3 votes) Average
Why not use 'how to'? (1 votes) Average
How to stop burst pipes? (1 votes) Average
Fat Black Holes (1 votes) Average
virtual strike public company? (1 votes) Average
Standardize Keypads (2 votes) Average
Problems Instead of Answers (5 votes) Average
Website for Ideas (1 votes) Average
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

The same notion applies to buying a pack versus buying cigarettes in smaller denomination. I have heard many smokers complain about having to buy a pack of 20-30 cigarettes when they actually want about 5 to, maybe, last them during a weekend on vacation. There is a market for smaller denomination packs, or even loose cigarettes (sell 1 at a time). A cigarette vending machine (couple quarters a pop) oughta do it. Better than bumming a smoke out of a passerby. There are people who end up not buying because they don't want 20 cigarettes sitting around tempting them.

Everybody's happy this way: the casual smoker, the manufacturers, and the passerby!

righthalf, May 20 2004

Cigarette companies in Canada tried to market smaller packs of cigarettes and they were quickly labelled 'kiddie packs' because a lot of kids bought them. They were cheaper and easier to hide from their parents. Advocates against smoking and the government then began to accuse the cigarette manufacturers of specifically marketing to kids. The result? They no longer exist.

Cigarette companies are in a damned if you do, damned if you don't situation right now. If they marketed smaller 'half' cigarettes, the same accusations would likely be raised. They could counter with 'smoking less means better health'... but I'm afraid they would lose even that.

Would smokers buy half-size cigarettes? We will likely never know...

asmodeus42, May 26 2004

I was actually searching the internet to see if these things are marketed because I have been wanting to buy them for some time now. I think it's a great idea. And it would be sweet because they have them in the Fifth Element. I think it would cut down drastically on my smoking and I wouldn't mind paying the extra money for them. I do, however, understand the marketing to children situation. Oh well, what is a smoker to do. I know... quit.

pathanks82, Aug 29 2004

I think they're called lady cigarettes. It's thinner and contain less tobacco.

jz928, Sep 11 2004

I think this is a good idea because being a smoker, I sometimes never finsh my cigarette or I dont have time to finish one. So having a smaller cigarette would likely be the best for people on the go.

gabs, Feb 05 2006

half-size cigarettes are very efficient for half-size persons.. uhmm,, sounds good to me.. but lets be sure that price is also half-size.. hahaha.

banana ranger, Feb 09 2006

This wouldn't work, because it would assist people in quitting. :/

Sonic Flash, Mar 14 2006

there are cigarettes of shorter length in india, not half the size of avg length but 7/10th and 8/10th of the avg length.

manju, Jan 07 2007

I believe Marlboro 72s are an attempt at that. I agree with several of the comments here.

I'll tell you I'm actually pretty happy about CVS's targeted advertising - whenever I buy a pack of cigarettes there and use my Extra Care Card, I get a coupon for Nicorette. I do appreciate that.

cyi, Jul 31 2007

You can always roll your own.

amyewhite, Nov 22 2007

Skid row liquor stores in the inner cities often sell cigarettes individually to vagrants, winos, etc. They keep them in a tray on the counter.

Belmont, Jan 07 2008

Great idea! I agree! I think larger cigarettes help keep people addicted. Shorter cigarettes could be marketted to help people quit.

MrCoder, Oct 09 2008

anyone wanting to do this, the solution is simple, i do it already. with roll your own, you can either fill the tube up half way (i prefer to leave a gap in the tube toward the filter so more of the tobacco is used and never burns the filter), or you can roll a regular cigarette and cut it in half.

lady cigarettes = lol -ette means female.... first it was a cigar, then it was a cigar-ette, now it will be a cigaretteette

myparadigm, Nov 01 2008

Why not make it quarter size? Call it a one puff or 2 puff cigarettes.Why not reduce the diameter of the cigrarettes to abt 2-3 mm?

pepindia007, Aug 20 2009