WhyNot?

How to Increase Organ Donation

Category: Questions
Responses: 3 (2 in support, 0 neutral, 1 in opposition)
Number of views: 3273
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Average AverageYour Rating:

Studies show that almost all Americans (85%) support organ donation, but the national donor consent rate is about 50%. How would you suggest promoting organ donation (in schools and the workplace...not through legislation)? If you support donation but haven't registered, why not?

big_bully, Jul 30 2004

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Better Brake Light (465 votes) Very strong
Elevator DeSelect (167 votes) Very strong
Airport charity (150 votes) Very strong
Ringtones for Landlines (31 votes) Very strong
Smarter ATM cards (27 votes) Very strong
Drivers Ed (26 votes) Very strong
Reverse Help Wanted Ads (16 votes) Very strong
Gentle Horn (19 votes) Very strong
Freebay (15 votes) Very strong
Overweight planes (19 votes) Very strong

Other ideas in category (Questions):

Poles apart (1 votes) Average
archery techniques (1 votes) Average
self powered generator (5 votes) Average
use Bluetooth to read RFID tag (2 votes) Average
Stock market (1 votes) Average
Salt water Fuel (1 votes) Average
Take Advantage of Marketers (2 votes) Average
Writing question (1 votes) Average
Public School Fundraising (5 votes) Average
Half-size Cigarettes? (20 votes) Very strong
Why buy np-bg1 here (3 votes) Weak
Improbable Motion (1 votes) Average
Why can't you tickle yourself? (2 votes) Average
Comments for negative votes (10 votes) Average
Perpetual motion (3 votes) Average
hydrogen from lightning (3 votes) Average
Energy of water (1 votes) Average
Encouraging Generosity (3 votes) Average
Equity sharing for renters (6 votes) Weak
day of 100,000 seconds (1 votes) Average
Aircraft tires (2 votes) Average
Nicotine Inhaler (2 votes) Average
Black hole point of view (3 votes) Weak
nuclear energy (3 votes) Weak
How to convert force to motion (4 votes) Average
ENERGY PRODUCTION (5 votes) Weak
Why don't they feel my pain? (1 votes) Average
Some ideas+ for Traffic (1 votes) Average
Fastest Man-Made Object (1 votes) Average
Space-Orbital Transfer (3 votes) Average
Fun Questions (3 votes) Average
Where are the stars? (4 votes) Average
I can C clearly now..or can I? (1 votes) Average
What happened to StarLite? (2 votes) Average
More Money (2 votes) Average
Curiousity (2 votes) Average
Keys order on key board (3 votes) Average
Using Why Not Ideas (9 votes) Strong
Dreams- A reality (1 votes) Average
Degree of agreement (1 votes) Average
Neutral vote (5 votes) Average
Prevent getting "plowed in"? (1 votes) Average
What's that smell? (3 votes) Average
Difference?? (4 votes) Average
Loose to Gain? (2 votes) Average
What am I missing? (2 votes) Average
Fragile (1 votes) Average
How to Increase Organ Donation (3 votes) Average
Why not use 'how to'? (1 votes) Average
How to stop burst pipes? (1 votes) Average
Fat Black Holes (1 votes) Average
virtual strike public company? (1 votes) Average
Standardize Keypads (2 votes) Average
Problems Instead of Answers (7 votes) Strong
Website for Ideas (1 votes) Average
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

Moving to opt-out (the defualt is that you are an organ donor unless you say otherwise) works. This is done is Spain and Belgium and both countries eliminted their waiting list.

Another option is forced choice where you force the person to either opt-in or opt-out when they renew their driver's license. You don't have to be a donor but you also can't not decide.

A third idea is to give people who are organ donors priority in recieving organ transplants. Their priority would be based on what fraction of their adult life they have been a donor.

Barry Nalebuff, Jul 30 2004

The opt-out approach conflicts severely with the American value system. I can't even remotely see that flying.

On the driver's license issue, it's my understanding that the donor card or sticker actually carries no legal weight. The word of your next of kin is the end-all, be-all.

This is the problem with the third idea too -- I don't directly get to control whether I "am" a donor or not. All I can do is convey to my wife my sincere wishes that she not hesitate a moment to break me up for spare parts. The decision will be hers. That's how I understand the law to be, anyway.

I think the solution to this problem is that we all need to talk to our families, making sure they know our intent to be a donor, and getting their consent to be donors as well.

kevinb9n, Aug 04 2004

How about this extension? Out prisons are overloaded. If you are in for a life sentence with no hope of parole, you could donate your organs now. Doing so, your next of kin would get a reasonable payment, say 25-50K and at the same time, free up prison space. Yeah, I know, it's a radical idea...

AJIdea, Aug 19 2004

It seems obvious that the only way to change our horrible percentage of approval for organs is to not ask families at all, but instead to put into operation a universal donor inquiry system. If filling out whether or not you want to be a donor is done at the same time as your taxes, or getting a driver's license, and if your decision is FINAL, as it so often isn't in the case of a family's distressed dissent, than our country's 6000+ deaths a year from lack of organs will plummet.

CollegeDean, Nov 01 2004

See http://www.lifesharers.com/Voluntary system to put organ donors higher on the priority list.

dumllama, Jun 29 2005

Why not use another mode of organ donation? We can use biotechnology in aiding us in getting organs with the use of the stem cell research that scientist have been doing for the past years. With stem cell research the objectives that they aim to do is to fight or find solutions for diseases like parkinsons and aids. Another objective of stem cell is also cloning. I heard they have successfully made a transgenic animal,which they call chimeras, that is a sheep who has a liver of a human. But it is modified so it is not yet sure if we can use it for human use.

Aiouie16, Feb 05 2006