WhyNot?

Cameras for speed control

Category: Traffic
Responses: 8 (3 in support, 0 neutral, 5 in opposition)
Number of views: 253
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Weak WeakYour Rating:

Use cameras integrated with radar to snap the picture and license plate info. for those who are speeding. This would free up our police resources to work on more pressing issues and make for more consistent speed enforcement. Fixed cameras can be placed in locations and mobile cameras can be used as needed.

doc13mil, Aug 04 2004

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Elevator DeSelect (126 votes) Very strong
Use metric in the USA (65 votes) Very strong
Refrigerator (88 votes) Very strong
Door locks (30 votes) Very strong
*Night Museums (13 votes) Very strong
Smarter ATM cards (25 votes) Very strong
Bathroom doors open out (24 votes) Very strong
Mute button for microwave keys (17 votes) Very strong
Finding a parking space (15 votes) Very strong
LED Christmas Lights (15 votes) Very strong

Other ideas in category (Traffic):

Comments from other members:

Add your comment

You can find such ideia working in Brazil and other countries in South America. It has worked very well until people began to remember where the fixed radars were placed. People run, brake close to radar and then speed again. Then government had the other idea to place mobile radars.For more info try http://www.dersa.sp.gov.br/rodovias/radar.asp

schertel, Aug 05 2004

Picture two cars on a four lane highway in a 40 mph zone, one traveling at 40 mph, one at 60 mph. They both get to the point the camera snaps the picture at the same time. Your camera goes off. Who gets the ticket?

Cameras have no judgement. A police officer can observe which vehicle is overtaking the other and issue the ticket to the correct party. The camera would likely ticket both. And if I was the guy doing 40 there would be no way to prove my innocence.

Hyenuf, Aug 05 2004

Photo radar is what it is called. Ontario Canada tried that, but quickly abandoned that (not sure why exactly). AFAIK there was a cottage indusry making/selling license plate covers that the camera flash would obscure.

classicsat, Aug 11 2004

This is already being implemented in Arizona (US) cities which use it at intersections, on main roads, and on highways. It is effective and useful here, and apparently accurate.

C2H6O, Jan 03 2006

I received a ticket for running a red light with a camera. It came in the mail with my picture in the intersection. I was very angry because the picture clearly showed a city bus right in front of me that blocked my view of the light and also came to an abrupt halt that stranded my in the intersection. Like the previous poster said, "cameras have no judgement". I would not have been ticketed by a human in that case.

ken3, Jan 06 2006

Someone is a little out of date here. This has been going on for years in most European countries.
Look up "speed camera map" in Google.
It is very effective, and either very popular or very unpopular depending on your bias.

ChrisF, May 18 2006