WhyNot?

Daytime license

Category: Licensing
Responses: 9 (8 in support, 0 neutral, 1 in opposition)
Number of views: 510
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Strong StrongYour Rating:

Some elderly people lose their night vision even as they retain their regular eyesight. While it would be dangerous for them to drive at night, they would have no problem driving safely during the day. In addition to the regular vision test given at the DMV, drivers should be required to pass a night vision test. Those who pass the former and fail the latter would be granted a driving license that is only valid during the day.

Curious Cat, Oct 14 2003

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Ending the war on drugs (207 votes) Very strong
This concept is great! (121 votes) Very strong
Reverse Ebay: Want to buy XYZ (63 votes) Very strong
like IMDB but for government (93 votes) Very strong
Refrigerator (93 votes) Very strong
Recycling Water (34 votes) Very strong
Cable TV (92 votes) Very strong
McDonalds Breakfast (60 votes) Very strong
Fast Food Ordering (31 votes) Very strong
Key Number (40 votes) Very strong

Other ideas in category (Licensing):

Comments from other members:

Add your comment

I think that is an excellent idea. I also think, that maybe starting at a particular age - folks should have to be required to take a yearly driving ability test and maybe attend a driving skills enhancement class of some kind.

In our community, there are a large number of older folks behind the wheel and they do not drive well. I have seen them driving down the wrong side of the road, moving at 20 mph below the posted speed limit, and swerving all over the road. It is a very dangerous situation.

tomdifran, Oct 27 2003

Additionally, I think there should be a ban on using hats whilst driving. In Norway, at least, everyone wearing a hat whilst driving, drive 20-30 km/h below the speed limit, actively denies you to pass them by going to the middle of the road, and speeding up in the moment you will pass them. They then decelerate to 20-30 km/h below the speed limit.

harald, Oct 30 2003

It's a valid idea but can it be regulated?Let's separate the night vision test from license renewal since in my locale license renewal only entails paying a fee.

Why not institute a national driver license standardthereby eliminating various state restrictions?Then; interstate truck drivers could be appropriately supervised, anyone moving could easily flip their license, and categories for day-driving may be implemented.

Also; instead of just paying a renewal fee, a databank could determine if a re-test, eye-test, or restriction should be imposed.

A side bar is:Despite the fear of 'big-brother', a driver's license is a valid form of identification that can be easily obtained. Why not include a fingerprint on the card in the process?

kim, Nov 01 2003

In regulating the Driver License provisions. We must remember that driving is not a right, it is a priviledge granted by the issuing state. If one is busted for various tickets the priviledge is revoked. Commercial Drivers are required in most states to have a D O T physical, if it is not passed to required standards, the CDL will be either not renewed, or revoked. Legislation can be introduced, and perhaps citing dangers on the road could be passed (if not to many older legislators get stubborn about "Age Discrimination"

ChrishelSr, Nov 05 2003

I'm surprised insurance companies haven't gotten more involved in these issues- they were the ones behind the CDL requirement, they could simply insist that drivers over a certain age take a night vision test to renew their insurance.

A national drivers license makes sense, as do uniform traffic rules. I was a professional driver for some years, and the contradictory nature of different states' traffic laws creates considerable confusion.

A national drivers license could contain a great deal of important information if it included a "smart card" chip. The chip could contain fingerprint and iris scanning information for indisputable identification. (The chip could also be scanned by automated roadside devices to issue traffic tickets- every technology has its dark side...)

Beaugrand, Dec 06 2004

In Britain, once you reach 70 you need a certificate from a doctor that you are capable of driving before you can renew your licence, and new certificate every 3 years. This covers not just night vision, but any other problems such as slow reaction times.

I disagree with a night driving ban. What happens if you got delayed in a traffic jam, are 30 minutes from home on a road where you cannot stop (Motorway/Autobahn) and the sun is going down ....?

ChrisF, Jul 20 2006

I'm not sure exactly how it worked but I knew a gentleman when I lived in Virginia, and his license was only for daylight driving. The way he explained it, if he needed to turn on his headlights, he wasn't supposed to be driving. It was effective because he didn't want to lose his license altogether.

jcameron76, May 22 2007