WhyNot?

Elevator Floor Number Undo

Category: Public
Responses: 7 (6 in support, 0 neutral, 1 in opposition)
Number of views: 1586
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Strong StrongYour Rating:

Why the elevator floor number setting are not undoable?? I mean once the floor # is set you cannot unset. Sometimes people fat-fingered the #, they can do nothing about it. Specially if the elevator is slow going up and down, the door is slow open and close. Someone could play practical joke by lighting up all the floor buttons on a 40-story building. There is nothing you could do about that.

can this be implemented? I don't forsee this is technically challenging IMO.

Thanks for looking.

highpitch, Sep 02 2004

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Better Brake Light (446 votes) Very strong
GPS and Digital Photos (173 votes) Very strong
Ending the war on drugs (247 votes) Very strong
Refrigerator (112 votes) Very strong
Audio-in Jacks in Cars (177 votes) Very strong
Elevator DeSelect (161 votes) Very strong
Airport charity (148 votes) Very strong
This concept is great! (141 votes) Very strong
Attachment Notation (137 votes) Very strong
like IMDB but for government (108 votes) Very strong

Other ideas in category (Public):

Skyscraper safety chutes (7 votes) Average
Police taxis (6 votes) Average
Elevator 'Door Open' Buttons (1 votes) Average
Elevator DeSelect (161 votes) Very strong
Financial Incompetency (8 votes) Weak
Government Spending Cut Idea (1 votes) Average
How about zero toll booths (14 votes) Weak
Piracy bait (2 votes) Average
Eliminate the Penny! (38 votes) Very strong
Tower of Babel for Gangs (2 votes) Average
Public Service Inventions (1 votes) Average
Save the Lanes (1 votes) Average
Civil conscription (3 votes) Average
Debit System for Parking Meter (5 votes) Average
Buy custom newsreader voices? (1 votes) Average
Smart elevators (4 votes) Average
Single Global Currency (12 votes) Very weak
Kid Friendly Bathrooms (3 votes) Average
Public Transportation Switch (2 votes) Average
Government Ebay (5 votes) Strong
Library Books - New Policy (9 votes) Average
Daylight Savings Time Reform (3 votes) Weak
free gas during evacuation (2 votes) Average
burglar-proof cash register (2 votes) Average
RFID CAR Registration (10 votes) Weak
bad driver hotline (4 votes) Weak
Another 9-11 (9 votes) Very weak
Pay-to-Cut. (7 votes) Average
free train power (6 votes) Average
Parking bill instead of fine (4 votes) Weak
Siren Alert traffic Lights (3 votes) Weak
anti-trust via jumbo taxes (2 votes) Average
Energy Saving Street Lights (3 votes) Average
A lite version of 9-1-1 calls (3 votes) Average
Red paint that doesn't fade (2 votes) Average
Put Cockroaches On Mars (7 votes) Average
Auto Doors for Pub Bathrooms (2 votes) Average
me for president ! (2 votes) Average
Drug house remover (17 votes) Very weak
National Water Balancing (3 votes) Average
save billions of dollars (5 votes) Weak
Restroom Pantyhose Dispensers (2 votes) Average
cure-all STD's (4 votes) Average
Fake Baghdad (5 votes) Weak
TOUCH SCREEN FOR ELEVATOR (1 votes) Average
Airplane Ejection Modules (6 votes) Weak
No more metro cards (9 votes) Strong
New Airport Metal Detectors (2 votes) Average
Metal detector flashlight (2 votes) Average
Baby Isolator (4 votes) Average
Voluntary inner prison (2 votes) Average
Privatized Libraries (6 votes) Weak
Tax Energy - Not Income (4 votes) Weak
Traceable Spray Paint Graffiti (3 votes) Weak
Elevator Floor Number Undo (7 votes) Strong
A crook or a banditt? (4 votes) Average
Movie Seats Trash Bin (4 votes) Average
passports (5 votes) Average
Solution Radio (1 votes) Average
Easy Change (3 votes) Average
QMatic tokens (1 votes) Average
Ground Based (1 votes) Average
Triangular escalator system (2 votes) Average
internet on planes... (1 votes) Average
Video billboards (5 votes) Weak
credit cards (2 votes) Average
credit cards (1 votes) Average
Ending 2X-a-year time shifting (5 votes) Average
BusQuest (5 votes) Strong
Cancel Elevator Button (6 votes) Strong
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

Hitting the button a second time would undo the call. You should also be able to undo the calling the elevator button from outside. Say you on the ground floor and the elevator stops on the way down to the basement. You could get on and then skip the stop on the way back up -- if there was a way to cancel the request.

Barry Nalebuff, Sep 02 2004

Barry,

I don't find I can cancel the request by "Hitting the button a second time". Where do you use the evlevator?

highpitch, Oct 08 2004

Possible disadvantages of this idea:

Anally retentive "high achieving" types would cancel your floor so they could get to their own floor faster, especially if the elevator is crowded and no-one else can get at the control panel.

Muggers could cancel your floor to trap you, or force you to get out on a floor of their choosing.

If the light bulb in the button fails, you won't know if you've selected your floor or not. You will probably press the button a few times waiting for the light to come on, and then will be stuck trying to remember if you pushed it an odd or even number of times.

Elevators stacked in multiple banks (e.g. in large high rise buildings) use a complicated algorithm to schedule the optimal arrival times of different elevators at different floors. Cancelling a floor after setting off but before arriving there would screw up the algorithm and cause an elevator "traffic jam", so the most efficient thing would be to still go to that floor anyway, obviating the advantage of cancelling.

At present, a stuck button usually results in the car always the visiting the affected floor, which is mildly annoying. With press on/off a stuck button could result in either _never_ visiting that floor, or doing so randomly. Either condition is much worse than the mild annoyance of always visiting it.

bugmenot, Jun 16 2007