WhyNot?

Tivo for Car Radio

Category: Radio
Responses: 31 (27 in support, 2 neutral, 2 in opposition)
Number of views: 3791
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Very strong Very strongYour Rating:

There have been times, that while driving to work or traveling, that I hear a new song and that I'd like to hear it again after it's finished playing. Instead, I have to wait until the radio station decides to play it again. Wouldn't it be nice to be able to just reach over and push a button and record the current song that is playing? There could maybe be just so much space (memory)in the unit, that would allow for like 5 or 10 songs and there would be no way to "burn" the music to tape or CD so as to not infringe a copyright. I know some folks are thinking, that by the time one decides to hit "record" the song could be half over - well, if the device used buffering like portable CD Players do - to prevent skipping, that wouldn't be a problem - hitting "record" would allow for the whole song to be recorded - as long as "record" was hit before the song ended.

tomdifran, Oct 16 2003

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Aerial pictures in flight (237 votes) Very strong
Audio-in Jacks in Cars (195 votes) Very strong
Better Brake Light (492 votes) Very strong
like IMDB but for government (120 votes) Very strong
Elevator DeSelect (171 votes) Very strong
Attachment Notation (145 votes) Very strong
Ending the war on drugs (269 votes) Very strong
This concept is great! (149 votes) Very strong
Refrigerator (123 votes) Very strong
Airport charity (154 votes) Very strong

Other ideas in category (Radio):

Comments from other members:

Add your comment

There is a Swedish startup that does this, it is called popcatcher.

I am not related to them, met them at Cebit Hannover 2003.

jules, Oct 25 2003

Better still, have it work via wireless connection back to your desktop, so you can program upcoming shows, channels, etc. I like Howard Stern, C-SPAN radio and even, I hate to admit NPR. It would be great to look at a website of upcoming times and then save that wirelessly to a deck in my car. When I started my morning drive I could listen to Howard and skip the 35 minute commercial breaks.

Better still, embed the technology in my cell phone, which I charge next to my computer anyway and then allw me to "plug in" my cell phone to my car stereo and listen to the programs off my cell through the car system.

ThousandFaces, Nov 26 2003

The next step: Add this capability to XM/Sirius Satellite Radio. They add tags to the songs/programs being played. The tags will act like program guide allowing users to filter particular songs, artists and albums.Hook this device with a large harddisk to store the songs over a period of time. Tags are used to name the files on disk, at leisure go through the harddisk keep the good stuff trash the rest.

abhidon, Jan 05 2004

This device got #10 in the Vaporware ratings for innovative products that were announced but never released. For more, see Wired.

rebolin, Jan 20 2004

Thought of this too but I took a bit different spin.

What if when you pressed the button, you were acknowledging that you wanted to purchase that track. A request was sent to a server that would forward the track to your email (or via FTP download) to your home computer. The service would automatically charge a pre-registered account or credit card.

dseif88429, Feb 21 2004

I think Sirius beat you to the punch. I recall reading a while back that they plan to release this type of service in upcoming radios.

Puddinhead, Feb 25 2004

How about a very simple device that allows for time shifting of radio programs. Just a recorder that can record multiple frequencies at various times. Then my morning commute would simply be channel surfing the recordings ... rather than listening to the commercials. A trunk mounted recorder with builtin tuner(s) would do most of the work. Then add a wireless controller for the driver to allow Fast-forward, reverse, skip, etc. Signal could be sent from trunk to dash-radio via FM transmitter (which is already done for some expansion components). As with the video deck, the user interface is key.

hopkinstx, May 14 2004

Sirius and XM Satellite radio now have devices that do somethihng similar. However, it's less useful for what you want than you might think. It simply requires too much user intervention. TiVo works because you set it and forget it. constantly pusing the record button and then trying not to record too much etc. would soon lose it luster.

My Sirius Sportster Replay lets me pause live radio and pick up where I left off, but it has no storage capability so you cannot record specific songs and keep them for later. Total storage is only 44 minutes. I find it marginally useful. XM's unit stores lots more, but I don't know how you store and recal what you've recorded.

WickSmith, Aug 20 2005

Copyright © Barry Nalebuff & Ian Ayres