WhyNot?

Observer sites

Category: Communities
Responses: 4 (3 in support, 0 neutral, 1 in opposition)
Number of views: 993
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Average AverageYour Rating:

Although official agencies to alert the nation over developing crises require personnel and funding and some sort of formal table of activities, there may be unsuspected problems that have symptoms which are somewhat vague but perhaps alarming to individuals who are aware that something peculiar is going on. Investigating all these speculations on suspected occurrences would probably be too much of a nuisance and too expensive for an agency which is devoted to concrete facts. Nevertheless, probably many indicators of nefarious or dangerous activity are ignored because there is no place for a vague suspicion to be put for expert examination. If various sites were set up on the internet as databases for experts to sift through that contained messages (that could be from anonymous sources) the general information retained by a researcher may be confirmed by some of these rather random postings and could lead to important information to catch a dangerous act before it occurs. Doubtless this kitchen midden of observations would contain stuff of fantasy and material placed by jokesters and over-suspicious idiots but it might collect important information missed by formal investigation agencies and could be a source of last resort sifted by computer programs for key words and phrases. At the moment there is no place to send such odd observations.

sand, Oct 16 2004

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Better Brake Light (446 votes) Very strong
GPS and Digital Photos (173 votes) Very strong
Ending the war on drugs (247 votes) Very strong
Aerial pictures in flight (218 votes) Very strong
Refrigerator (112 votes) Very strong
Audio-in Jacks in Cars (177 votes) Very strong
Elevator DeSelect (161 votes) Very strong
Airport charity (148 votes) Very strong
Attachment Notation (137 votes) Very strong
like IMDB but for government (108 votes) Very strong

Other ideas in category (Communities):

I have an idea (1 votes) Average
Teaching Ethical Reasoning (12 votes) Average
Prisoners teach school kids (9 votes) Weak
Community service/fund-raising (2 votes) Average
New category (1 votes) Average
Mine shaft cities (5 votes) Strong
Daycare (2 votes) Average
Witness Pay (7 votes) Weak
Friendsmind.com - Ask Anything (2 votes) Average
Summer Camp for Adults (4 votes) Average
Drug Free Communities (6 votes) Weak
Online Yard Sales (4 votes) Average
People-friendly Jewelry (3 votes) Average
HUMAN ELECTRO POWER (5 votes) Strong
The Ultimate Plastic House (3 votes) Average
Home Volunteering (2 votes) Average
Blind Picture Finding Service (1 votes) Average
Higher Fines for SUVs (14 votes) Weak
Unadopted Children (4 votes) Average
Ending cigarette butt litter (8 votes) Average
habitat for humanity (3 votes) Average
Magazines for the Blind (2 votes) Average
Public Workshop (7 votes) Strong
No more Icy and freezed roads (3 votes) Average
Social Credit Card (3 votes) Average
Tax Energy - Not Income (5 votes) Weak
Freecycle for the Blind (1 votes) Average
Spend A Penny fundraising idea (1 votes) Weak
Three Great Ideas (2 votes) Average
Community Specific Craigslist (3 votes) Average
Accountability Manager (1 votes) Average
share Drive (2 votes) Average
Currency for the Homeless (8 votes) Average
nonprofit soccer academy india (1 votes) Average
Toys Garage Sale (1 votes) Average
Referral and Network Marketing (1 votes) Average
How to prevent aggressions. (9 votes) Weak
Star Night (8 votes) Strong
Promote Religious Rationality (5 votes) Weak
Obnoxious pedestrians (4 votes) Average
neighborrow.com (2 votes) Average
Neighborhood media offices (4 votes) Weak
Suggestion for climate change (9 votes) Very weak
City bulk transport (4 votes) Average
Public Memorials (2 votes) Average
The 'mission movement' again (2 votes) Average
www.pilgrim.web (3 votes) Average
A New Way to Water Plants (2 votes) Average
Highway markers (3 votes) Average
Wikicity council - democracy (4 votes) Average
Bike Lock Meters (6 votes) Average
Slanted Curbs (6 votes) Weak
Observer sites (4 votes) Average
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

sand: Your post was difficult to read. You did not use paragraphs to give the readers a visual brea.

polohay, Oct 16 2004

Sorry. I will try to put in a brea here and there on future submissions.

sand, Oct 16 2004

Count me against this one. It sounds like a breeding ground for paranoia, libel, harassment and vigilantism.

But if you're really in favor of it, do a Google search for "Conspiracy" ...I'm sure you'll find existing public forums somewhere.

MikeMol, Oct 18 2004

I agree that the proposed sites can be dangerous. It is a very valid criticism but I wonder if the country is more in danger from malicious reports than it is by catching something really dangerous that could result in a major terrorist attack. The information must be handled professionally with due consideration for civil rights. Up to this point the failure of federal legal and police agencies to properly validate and assess incoming information is a real concern.

sand, Oct 18 2004

I imagine each of these sites needs to be dedicated to a particular event. Something like this could be helpful if it collected medical information...if a number of individuals in one area report that they have particular symptoms, it could indicate that some sort of disease is going around. Epidemics can go unnoticed for awhile because no-one is in a position to see the "big picture".

Anyway, the big issue is figuring out what sort of data we want to track and how to convince people to submit the data (it takes time to submit data)... then how is it analyzed efficiently. Maybe this will work in 20 years when our communication and automatic analysis systems have developed a bit more.

dumllama, Jul 07 2005