WhyNot?

Attrcating students

Category: Education
Responses: 3 (2 in support, 0 neutral, 1 in opposition)
Number of views: 1044
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Average AverageYour Rating:

Akin to a Barry/Ian proposal in the book, could universities not offer a premium rate performance bond deal to students under which poor class outcomes are compensated as a way of making a reality of their promises on employability? For example, I could offer my (wholly fictitious) class a deal like this:

'If the average salary of students in the current BA Hons(Basket Weaving) course two years after graduation is ten per cent less than the average for the UK, we will refund 5% of your course fee'.

Making an offer to refund the fee on that basis gives an incentive to do better in class - after all, who wants only the 5% refund of fee if they can shine and get a job paying 10% more and get the 5% courtesy of less well placed students? If all students acted this way, there might be no need for refunded fees any way and student performance could be improved. (The moral hazard issue here is, I'm sure, a bit trickier to handle than I've suggested, but this is my first outing for this idea!)

The weakness of the approach is that it assumes rational students, good information on national salary levels across all fields (basket weaving students may not just enter basket weaving) and - most important of all - that luck isn't a big factor in job placements by 2 years from graduation. It assumes that salaries for year 1 after graduation are correlated with those at year 2 (i.e. no abnormal salary hikes or salary drops, or that they are at least normally distributed) and that there is a correlation between college performance and salary generally.

There is lots to refine here (for instance in my offer to the class above is it 'average salary of students' or 'top quartile'; is it '10% less than the average for the UK' or '10% less than the average for basket weavers in the UK', or '10% less than the average for basket weaving course graduates in the UK'?).

Then again I may just be plain wrong.

MarkUK, Mar 15 2006

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Other ideas in category (Education):

Education by employer (1 votes) Average
ebooks (2 votes) Average
Brain Games For Free Time (2 votes) Average
Learn how to Learn (5 votes) Average
Health Belongs in Classrooms (3 votes) Average
Honor Roll Slideshow (1 votes) Average
Reading illegal=literacy (6 votes) Average
Microphonesystem in Lectures (1 votes) Average
Wash your mouth out with soap (7 votes) Average
public audio university (15 votes) Very strong
Cheating 2 (7 votes) Weak
Flexible textbooks (3 votes) Average
Pre-birth language (1 votes) Average
Color Graphing Calculators (5 votes) Average
Wikipedia RSS Feeds (4 votes) Average
Job training in High School (5 votes) Average
College English/Math in H.S. (3 votes) Average
Schools jobsite (2 votes) Average
An improved driving test (3 votes) Average
Capitalist College (15 votes) Strong
Religious Education (1 votes) Average
Credit Education (4 votes) Average
Copy Our Way to Success (1 votes) Average
Create A National Curriculum (1 votes) Average
A New Kind of Textbook (1 votes) Average
No more books!! (6 votes) Average
SAT scores ~ tutor pay (5 votes) Average
Kids & the Elderly (3 votes) Average
Teaching High School (2 votes) Average
High IQ (6 votes) Average
Class summaries on line (2 votes) Average
High Tech dissemination (2 votes) Average
Economics is ... ? (2 votes) Average
My Ideal Schooling Structure (1 votes) Average
Online GED (3 votes) Average
In-Classroom Camera (3 votes) Average
DORM ROOM PREVIEW (3 votes) Average
To infinity, and beyond (2 votes) Average
Kindle for students (4 votes) Average
shuufabet revised (4 votes) Average
Customized Travel Guides (2 votes) Average
Watch and Learn (2 votes) Average
large-scale textbk review web (3 votes) Average
Plagiarism (2 votes) Average
no drop out policy (3 votes) Average
fold-up ebook (3 votes) Average
School-Specific PDA (4 votes) Average
Graduate School Nap Time (6 votes) Strong
Radical Public Ed Proposal (3 votes) Average
Shuufabet/truly phonetic (1 votes) Average
Timer in Kid's room (3 votes) Average
Cheating 1 (8 votes) Very weak
virtual crowds raise awareness (3 votes) Average
Professor Zapper!!! (9 votes) Strong
Membership (2 votes) Average
Learn to edit Wikipedia (1 votes) Average
Why Not Higher Ed Diploma? (2 votes) Average
Test (1 votes) Average
Textbook tablet (2 votes) Average
moderate the teachers (8 votes) Weak
Credibility Database (3 votes) Average
Sim Project Management (4 votes) Average
question rating buzzer (21 votes) Average
Mandatory Phys-Ed for MBAs (19 votes) Strong
Cell phone signal jammers (8 votes) Average
Idea/Solution Communities (2 votes) Average
Wiki Notes (1 votes) Average
Out of Africa (3 votes) Average
Yale SOM + iTunes (19 votes) Very strong
0.5 Credit Internship Assignme (6 votes) Average
Attrcating students (3 votes) Average
Lowering debt of best students (7 votes) Weak
Submitting assignments (4 votes) Weak
Subtraction BEFORE Addition (12 votes) Very strong
Sound Proof (3 votes) Average
Honest (3 votes) Weak
School-Issued PDAs (2 votes) Average
Math-Leading or misleading us? (3 votes) Weak
DLS-C COMLAB (1 votes) Average
Foreign Expressions (2 votes) Average
Commuter Naps (4 votes) Average
Stand-up Comedy in line (6 votes) Average
N. Ireland solution? (4 votes) Average
Surplus paper (3 votes) Average
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

There's something in it. Of course universities don't have any money anyway. What about the drp op out rate which I think is currently sitting about 25%. People like me who disappear without a trace for three years?

Do like the concept though. lets see if we can't get it to work out.

MDH, Mar 23 2006

This makes no sense at all. The potential refund is not any more likely if the student does well. Quite the contrary! If the student does poorly after graduation, it will bring the classes overall salary average down, which increases the likelyhood that they will be under the cut off for the refund. In other words, they're more likely to get the refund if they do poorly! Of course, they will make more money if they get a higher paying job, but that's true regardless of the refund. The most this proposal would do is encourage pessimistic under-achievers to take the class.

Dwane Anderson, Jan 06 2007