WhyNot?

Tagging Audio

Category: Internet
Responses: 3 (2 in support, 1 neutral, 0 in opposition)
Number of views: 381
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Average AverageYour Rating:

Summary

The idea is a part of the Web 2.0 wave. The main concept is to tag the contents of an audio, may it be a podcast, song, audio book or audio clip.

A tag should be readable/writable on a specific timestamp in the track. Which is then searchable by the software.

There are two ways in implementing the tags, [1] embedding in the metadata of the audio or [2] storing them in a database.

[1] The tags will be encoded in the comments field in the ID3v2 or APEv2 for MP3 files and Vorbis Comment for Vorbis and FLAC files. The tags will then be parsed when read.

Pros:- No other place needed for the storage of the tags also modifiable "by hand".- Plugins could be made for mainstream media players to parse and code the tags.

Cons:- I don't know. Metadata corruption perhaps? Or the tags are not that "secured"?

[2] The tags and their respective timestamps are stored in a database then the audio file could be track in a certain way, some that came up with:

- A hash of the track will be stored in the database which will then be matched to a hash calculation done by the client computer.- Placing an ID on the metadata of the track which should match in the database.

Pros:- Centralized server

Cons:- Centralized server- Requires an Internet connection

Tools/References:ID3APEv2Vorbis CommentPHP PEAR MP3_ID packagePHP PEAR File_Ogg package

jploh, Apr 24 2006

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Cross-Patenting (2 votes) Average

Other ideas in category (Internet):

AgedAdvice.com (2 votes) Average
NerdMakeover.com (2 votes) Average
Integrate Phone and email! (1 votes) Average
My Personal Library on Amazon (5 votes) Strong
RestyleMe.com (2 votes) Average
Better Search Results (5 votes) Average
Healing Viruses (2 votes) Average
Google Porn (7 votes) Weak
face recognition search engine (2 votes) Average
Tech Spec Plugins (1 votes) Average
Ability to Recall E-mail (5 votes) Average
automatic blog cross-posting (1 votes) Average
Directions Route Options (6 votes) Strong
Reverse Ebay: Want to buy XYZ (57 votes) Very strong
Reverse Ebay (13 votes) Very strong
GPS from Photosynth or similar (2 votes) Average
Online Biography project (1 votes) Average
Second-hand Mkt. - Gift Cards (8 votes) Average
IOUs on Friendster, MySpace... (3 votes) Average
Internet pornography solution. (13 votes) Weak
Get rid of the WWW prefix (17 votes) Weak
Extra Storage Space (2 votes) Average
Require Porn sites to be .sex (68 votes) Very strong
Animated Emoticons at Why Not (2 votes) Average
Drag-n-Drop Files to Webpage (4 votes) Average
Malleable Forums (3 votes) Average
Buyers pay reverse auction fee (2 votes) Average
Map-Based Travel Guide (4 votes) Average
Version Grabbing (1 votes) Average
A truly free market (1 votes) Average
Testimonial Website for an EX (3 votes) Average
Mapquest for Walkers (10 votes) Very strong
Better than outdated magazines (2 votes) Average
Electronic Signatures (4 votes) Average
Local Online Service Auctions (2 votes) Average
Porno Viewing Time Counter (4 votes) Average
Blog-ring post aggregator (3 votes) Average
Google Tune (2 votes) Average
freeBay (5 votes) Average
Tracking trains like flights (3 votes) Average
Cell connect (3 votes) Average
Tagging Audio (3 votes) Average
Kidnapping Fedex Shipments (3 votes) Average
Co-operative Broadband (4 votes) Average
Underline anchors (2 votes) Average
Ebay Eye (2 votes) Average
An Open Search engine (2 votes) Average
Grab a shovel (2 votes) Average
Mailing Lists for Any Website (0 votes) Very weak
Online Polling (2 votes) Average
One User Name & Password (3 votes) Average
Good Spam (11 votes) Very strong
Innovative Olympics (6 votes) Average
Data manager (password, addres (2 votes) Average
Why Not Navigation? (1 votes) Average
Intuitive domain name system (4 votes) Average
Ex/Import util. for del.icio.u (2 votes) Average
Postal Address Management (3 votes) Average
SuperWiki (3 votes) Average
Fare Reduction Alert (1 votes) Average
Graphical Evolution (3 votes) Average
Multiple Home Pages (3 votes) Average
mozilla printability detection (2 votes) Average
Reading long texts in browser (2 votes) Average
Anon. Net Access (6 votes) Average
Smarter mail speller (3 votes) Average
Recursive Trackback (3 votes) Weak
Hypefilter for news feeds (2 votes) Average
Window on the World website (2 votes) Average
Audio Email (4 votes) Average
Search-in-store (2 votes) Average
Zip Codes on Location Websites (2 votes) Average
Audio Websites (5 votes) Average
Open Packets (2 votes) Average
Date Code Web Pages (4 votes) Average
Rebay (3 votes) Average
keyboard (5 votes) Average
ISHN Numbers (1 votes) Average
Digital Pictures Archiving (1 votes) Average
More security level groups (1 votes) Average
Commity Wi-Fi meets GRID (2 votes) Average
On holiday (2 votes) Average
A Letters To The Editor site (2 votes) Average
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

Three comments:

1. Is musicbrainz.org relevant here?

2. Accuracy of ID3 tag database. Read discussion thread here: http://ask.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=06/01/23/2135212

3. I foresee an invention waiting to happen. Read my quick links here: http://joelogs.blogspot.com/2006/03/i-foresee-invention-waiting-to-happen.html

joelogs, Apr 24 2006

With so many slightly different duplicates of hacked podcasts floating around, how would you limit the duplication?