WhyNot?

Grow food using salt water.

Category: Food
Responses: 5 (3 in support, 1 neutral, 1 in opposition)
Number of views: 2672
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Average AverageYour Rating:

I am generally against genetically engineered food, but I have thought of a use for it.<BR>Genetically engineer a food plant (doesn't matter which one, rice, wheat, potatoes, ...) so that it can survive on sea water irrigation. there are plenty of plants to get the genes from (seaweed, Mangrove), but none (or nearly none) are edible.

<B>Advantage:</B> all those water-starved places that are using scarce fresh water for irrigation of marginal land can use sea water. No de-salination plant necessary and no diverting of water causing rivers and lakes to dry out.

You would have to make sure the run-off was kept away from fresh water rivers and lakes, but you could irrigate lots of desert and semi-desert areas near the sea and let the run-off all run back into the sea.

OK, there is an energy requirement to pump the water up from the sea, but there is that at present when water is transported over long distances for irrigation.

ChrisF, May 24 2006

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Audio-in Jacks in Cars (177 votes) Very strong
GPS and Digital Photos (173 votes) Very strong
Elevator DeSelect (161 votes) Very strong
Airport charity (148 votes) Very strong
This concept is great! (141 votes) Very strong
Ziploc chip bags (104 votes) Very strong
Refrigerator (112 votes) Very strong
Use metric in the USA (99 votes) Very strong
McDonalds Breakfast (65 votes) Very strong
touch screen restaurant menu (55 votes) Very strong

Other ideas in category (Food):

SEE SALT (2 votes) Average
Lower cost refrigeration (1 votes) Average
Just Add Eggs (8 votes) Strong
Poverty Reduction + Enviroment (1 votes) Average
Human Chow (8 votes) Strong
Frequent Dining Card (2 votes) Average
front yard farms (4 votes) Average
Grow food using salt water. (5 votes) Average
Sour Cream in a squeeze bottle (4 votes) Average
Pringles Spring (1 votes) Average
Better Peanut Butter Jar (4 votes) Average
Bread Loaf in a Box, not a Bag (2 votes) Average
Chocolate Filled Marshmallows (6 votes) Strong
Moist microwave baking (1 votes) Average
Better Chewing Gum (2 votes) Average
Colored Salt (17 votes) Strong
Sample as You Go (1 votes) Average
The Seed Machine (2 votes) Average
No more liquid honey mess (2 votes) Average
cow shares (3 votes) Average
Colored salt (6 votes) Strong
Free paper plates (5 votes) Average
Flavored ice cream cones (3 votes) Average
Instant Cold Drink (2 votes) Average
End individual packaging (3 votes) Average
Sally's Apizza for all (17 votes) Strong
New Restaurant Idea. (7 votes) Average
Refrigerator Replenisher (3 votes) Average
"Quieter Packaging" (2 votes) Average
Chinese chances (3 votes) Average
cow shares (3 votes) Average
biotic dustbins (1 votes) Average
Global food and culture court (1 votes) Average
Warm drink vending machines (7 votes) Strong
Ready-To-Drink Masala Chai (2 votes) Average
MiniMeal (vnding mchine food) (2 votes) Average
Volunteer Soylent Green (2 votes) Average
Main course protein bars (2 votes) Average
New Type of Restaurant (2 votes) Average
Laser crust (1 votes) Average
The RIGHT Welfare (3 votes) Average
container - food packaging (2 votes) Average
Stick-O-Butter (2 votes) Average
Canned hot coffee/tea (6 votes) Average
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Milk (1 votes) Average
microwavable cake (3 votes) Average
Milk Carton Indicator (11 votes) Strong
Cream Cheese Bagel Cereal (3 votes) Average
Resealable Containers (1 votes) Average
Milk in cool pack (1 votes) Average
Food for Ethiopians (1 votes) Average
Mood ring for baby bottles (5 votes) Average
Edible dog leash (9 votes) Weak
Buttler for Hire (3 votes) Average
Wastage packaging (1 votes) Average
food tubes (7 votes) Strong
Home Cooked Meals To-Go! (14 votes) Strong
Avoiding Lady and the Tramp (5 votes) Average
No Food Pill (3 votes) Weak
Compartmented Fridge (2 votes) Average
Taste of your city company (4 votes) Average
Celeburrito! (2 votes) Average
Ingredient Itemisation Service (2 votes) Average
Personal popcorn (1 votes) Average
Round bottom yoghurt container (2 votes) Average
Mini Liquor Shot Bottles (2 votes) Average
Fresh water source (4 votes) Average
Vegetarian (4 votes) Average
daddy can cook (5 votes) Average
Populate The Oceans Afresh (3 votes) Weak
Sugar Sheets (4 votes) Average
plastic baby food containers (4 votes) Average
instafreeze (3 votes) Average
Auto Clean Table (1 votes) Average
Double handled cook's knife (2 votes) Average
Anti heartburn (4 votes) Average
Simulating steak 4 vegetarians (4 votes) Average
Validating Decaf Coffee (3 votes) Average
Serving the right meal (2 votes) Average
photo-meat labelling (5 votes) Weak
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

I posted almost the same idea quite a while ago. But if seaweed is used as the basic template modified with genetic additions from edible foods the food can be grown in the sea surrounding the areas of continents so there is no need to pump seawater onto land and poison it with salt. There is a great deal of fertilizer runoff into the Gulf of Mexico which could be taken up by sea grown crops and which now disrupt the ecology of the sea. The growth could also be beneficial in providing places to encourage other marine life which would be a secondary source.The floating farms could be designed to withstand rough weather and harvesting could be done with specialized marine machinery.

sand, May 24 2006

One problem assosiated with using salt water for irrigation would be that after a period of time the salt would build up in the soil to such a degree that nothing useful would grow. This is the reason there are not a lot of plants on the Bonneville Salt Flats or fish in the Great Salt Lake in Utah.

Hyenuf, May 24 2006

Salt water would build up, but it should reach a plateau so long as there is a run-off.
The places you describe are inland seas with no run off, the water just evaporates and the salt builds up over the centuries. There is a similar problem where you have fresh water irrigation without runoff, over years salts and fertiliser build up in the soil until it becomes infertile.

ChrisF, May 24 2006

According to my anthro prof, salt contamination results in practically irreversible damage to the soil. Salt water is able to ascend columns of drainwater from standard irrigation, much like osmosis within our own bodies.

nayhem, May 25 2006

The anthropology tie-in I forgot to mention is that such a failure of industrialized agriculture (which America is apparently destined for) results in state collapse.

nayhem, May 25 2006

The floating farms idea presented by SAND is exactly what I thought of too but the details needn't require a specific location. Since like sea weed, which is edible and used in SUSHI all the time the farms are floating and can be relocated as weather and tides permit. We currently move parts of oil rigs and other large constructions over the sea. There is another problem to be resolved here and that is the means by which to do this. But I believe we are already half way there.

Someday the sea is going to provide everything we need and as with other forms of evolution a we might adapt by growing gils.

winsum, Jul 12 2006

What if we use aquaponics, and develop a process of plant that take the salt out of the water, developing fresh water with a less salt per million so that food can be grown ie: animals, vetegables and plants. Food for thought IF anyone nows of plants that take salt out of water or plants that grow in salt water email me murph@haponicsfarmsUSA. ThanksKeith Murphy

Haponics, Sep 20 2009