WhyNot?

Serial numbers for music CDs

Category: Business
Responses: 6 (5 in support, 0 neutral, 1 in opposition)
Number of views: 2135
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Average AverageYour Rating:

The computer industry asks users to register their software to help prevent piracy. Why not the same for CDs? Instead of using technology to track and punish people who copy songs, why not provide some incentive for people to make a legitimate purchase? Perhaps registered owners could earn concert tickets, free merchandise, or get access to exclusive online chats with the artist for registering. It's impossible to stop people from copying audio, but you can give them a reason not to.

-- Drew

p.s. Furthermore, it might not hurt the cause if the price was reduced and the quality of the music was improved... people don't want to pay for it because it's not worth what they're asking.

arothman, Oct 31 2003

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Better Brake Light (492 votes) Very strong
Cable TV (97 votes) Very strong
This concept is great! (149 votes) Very strong
like IMDB but for government (120 votes) Very strong
Refrigerator (123 votes) Very strong
Reverse Ebay: Want to buy XYZ (74 votes) Very strong
McDonalds Breakfast (70 votes) Very strong
Ring for Service @ Restaurant (40 votes) Very strong
Key Number (44 votes) Very strong
Facebook + Craigslist (37 votes) Very strong

Other ideas in category (Business):

how to get rid of loose coins. (38 votes) Very strong
What really motivates us (2 votes) Average
shopping profile (1 votes) Average
All-In-One Date Spot (3 votes) Average
Workout Site (3 votes) Average
all in one i.d system (8 votes) Weak
Favorite Foods of Celebrities (4 votes) Average
Just Pharma (3 votes) Weak
no more subsidies (5 votes) Average
Electric Pram (8 votes) Average
cheap flights (1 votes) Average
Money from Add-Ons (1 votes) Average
Laundromat Bar (1 votes) Average
Tabacco Supermarket (2 votes) Weak
Supermarket Cart GPS (2 votes) Average
"We Picket 4 U" Picketing Biz (8 votes) Average
New Haven Restaurant Delivery (5 votes) Average
NEW SYNERGETICAL MARKETING & S (1 votes) Average
Jetson Burger (4 votes) Average
Government as a businessmen (2 votes) Average
GEAR CONVERTER (1 votes) Average
New Restaurant-Table Idea (2 votes) Average
Weekly Good Newspaper (3 votes) Average
Touch Tone Trivia (1 votes) Average
Team Building- Dragon boat (1 votes) Average
Restaurant Service (6 votes) Average
Restaurant service lights (19 votes) Very strong
Removable File Folder Labels (1 votes) Average
Good things come to those... (4 votes) Weak
send post to email address (9 votes) Strong
T-Shirts that show your Tweets (1 votes) Average
T-Shirts that guide the way (1 votes) Average
Idea to Company (5 votes) Strong
A NEW Calendar (11 votes) Weak
ID Card (1 votes) Average
Monopoly Wallet (1 votes) Average
Idea Architects (2 votes) Average
Tattoo Advertising (2 votes) Average
Global Taxis You Can Trust (2 votes) Average
Shipping & Unloading Gasoline (3 votes) Weak
Local Coupon Web Site (3 votes) Average
P2P Movie Exchange (2 votes) Average
Virtual wall paint and decor (5 votes) Average
Everything is EQUAL (11 votes) Very weak
fast food genius (3 votes) Average
Doggy Doo-Away (3 votes) Average
Airport Valet Service (2 votes) Average
One world Resturant (4 votes) Average
supermarket purchase history (7 votes) Strong
Electronic Highlighter (3 votes) Average
AC Plug in your car (4 votes) Average
Skill arcades with cash prizes (1 votes) Average
Credit card with finger pirint (1 votes) Average
Worry-free wallet loss (2 votes) Average
Online Fitness Community (1 votes) Average
Personalized Movie Experience (5 votes) Average
SPORTS FAN CHANNEL (1 votes) Average
21st. century breakfast (1 votes) Average
StumbleUpon for iPhone Apps. (13 votes) Very strong
Pineapple Farm and Paper Pulp (2 votes) Average
xPhone to xmit local info (2 votes) Average
Pizza Truck (4 votes) Average
CREDIT CARD MACHINE (1 votes) Average
Services Marketplace w/Penalty (1 votes) Average
Movie Delivery (3 votes) Average
Computermarket (3 votes) Average
Voice SMS Built Into Your Car (2 votes) Average
Shoe Box Inventory Idea (2 votes) Average
U.S.A. Store (3 votes) Average
SelfSufficient HomelessShelter (4 votes) Average
No More Messed Up Orders (5 votes) Average
Universal Loyalty Card (6 votes) Average
Arctic submerged Ships (1 votes) Average
Supermarket super website (1 votes) Average
Retail - Club (3 votes) Average
Re-inventing freight transport (2 votes) Average
Solar Cell Phones (3 votes) Average
Transferable Loan (1 votes) Average
Water Purchase (1 votes) Average
Business Quality Assurance (4 votes) Average
Hand Gestures (1 votes) Average
Name your own... flight? (2 votes) Average
Revolutionize Shopping (2 votes) Average
economic feratures for whynot (1 votes) Average
JET Program for China. (2 votes) Average
Retail/Salon Dental Cleaning (2 votes) Average
The SOMEX-The SOM Exchange (4 votes) Average
Electronic Grocery Coupons (2 votes) Average
Email Mail Service (1 votes) Average
New auto insurance tracking (2 votes) Average
Name a New Name Service (1 votes) Average
Audio RFPs (1 votes) Average
Buy the exxon valdez. (1 votes) Average
The Protest Shop (1 votes) Average
Books a la Netflix (29 votes) Very strong
Trade in your house (4 votes) Average
Sweet Smelling Light Bulbs (2 votes) Average
Absolute Zero Emissions (1 votes) Average
neganews (3 votes) Average
Wi Shoppe - Seein is Believin (1 votes) Average
Speed Pass For Garages (4 votes) Average
Referal Program With retailer (2 votes) Average
Condo for tech entrepreneurs (2 votes) Average
instant restocking for stores (1 votes) Average
A New Kind of Radio (1 votes) Average
Change Card (3 votes) Average
Save the change (1 votes) Average
Find the Right Dive Shop (1 votes) Average
Emotive Shareholding (2 votes) Average
distributed book rental (7 votes) Strong
Builder Customer Service (2 votes) Average
Weigh drive-through orders (4 votes) Average
Lock-In Gas/Electricity Option (1 votes) Average
Holiday as business idea sourc (1 votes) Average
Secretarial support show (1 votes) Average
Business community (1 votes) Average
Customer support equality (3 votes) Average
Luggage Cases for Hire/Storage (2 votes) Average
Low Cost Business Centers (1 votes) Average
Grocery Service (1 votes) Average
Personal Chef Info (1 votes) Average
Dog (2 votes) Average
Woman's Car Dealership (4 votes) Weak
Enetrepreneur High School (3 votes) Average
Rating Private High Schools (1 votes) Average
Apartment Auction (1 votes) Average
Effective Job Search Website (1 votes) Average
Rate Seminars/ Conf Web (1 votes) Average
Convenient Car Buying (1 votes) Average
Online Bookstore (1 votes) Average
Auction Dealer CRM (2 votes) Average
High-End Wanteds List (1 votes) Average
Renting Videos Online (1 votes) Average
Africa for Weekend Warriors (26 votes) Very strong
SeeCC- Climate Change Channel (5 votes) Average
Business Card Cross marketing (3 votes) Average
Sensor to find objects (2 votes) Average
Health Life Insurance (1 votes) Average
IMPROVED SPORTS BAR (2 votes) Average
In-house book search system (2 votes) Average
Kinetic Cell Phone Battery (10 votes) Very strong
The Cargo Purse (1 votes) Average
Service for B-School Students (11 votes) Weak
GEN-RAIL2 (5 votes) Weak
Gift packing (3 votes) Average
GEN-RAIL (4 votes) Average
Online Auctions in Reverse (1 votes) Average
Serial numbers for music CDs (6 votes) Average
Machine readable documents (8 votes) Strong
Math Bomb Ends © War! (5 votes) Weak
Creating a Workgroup (2 votes) Average
RFID for drawings (6 votes) Strong
Luxury Bus Service (2 votes) Average
International souvenir shop (2 votes) Average
Simplifying Infrastructure (4 votes) Weak
Trade access (2 votes) Average
WhyNot as new mrktplace (8 votes) Strong
ID verification thru contacts (4 votes) Average
Telecom (2 votes) Average
Solving Small Business Problem (3 votes) Average
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

If you're suggesting sweepstakes, US law requires that anyone be able to enter, not just purchasers of a product. Instructions are usually provided in the small print of the sweepstakes announcement as to where you can mail a 3x5 card with specified information. So that won't work as an enticement.

If you're suggesting that everyone who buys a CD be given free merchandise, either the labels will have to increase the price of CDs to compensate, or they will have to take a smaller cut of the CD price as profits. They are not likely to do either -- they might do the latter, but only as a gimmick on an album or two. They're not going to slash their profits down across the board by a significant percentage.

Access to online content seems like a better idea, and makes the most financial sense, as it wouldn't cost the labels significantly. However, this is not something that would appeal to anyone except the most hardcore of fans. Most people just want to listen to the music, or if they want any information about the band, they can get it from countless free websites. Furthermore, whatever "exclusive" content that is put on the website, if it is compelling in any way, will just be downloaded and redistributed on filesharing networks just as the music itself is redistributed.

Face it, music and music-related resources are just not worth all that much in a world with so much music already in existence and more being produced every day, because it's so damn cheap and easy to produce and distribute music thanks to the advance of technology.

transitionality, Oct 31 2003

Well, it wouldn't be so much a "sweepstakes" as it would be like those "send 4 UPC codes and get this free toy" kind of thing. Or they could use the serial for the CD as an access number to an online chat or some other exclusive non-distributable "experience" instead of downloadable content.

As for the price of the CDs, if the incentive to buy boosts the sales appropriately, they shouldn't have to raise the prices. I mean, if they're hurting for sales now and people are buying at $18 a piece, they could stand to keep them at $18 if sales were on the rise again.

The overall point here is that incentives for purchasing are a more effective way to invest than anti-piracy schemes and litigation. You can't stop pirates, but you can encourage honesty.

arothman, Nov 03 2003

Wilco allowed those who bought their previous album to listen to their EP online. They used the serial number as means for verification.

sam3000, Nov 10 2003

CDs are reproduced by stamping, not recording, so an embedded serial number int he cd or tracks wouldn't work.

However a serial number or email address could be added to downloaded tracks - but owuld be easy to remove with software.

bradjensen, Jan 06 2004

The large cost of starting and maintaining the IT infastructure necessary to track millions of registered CD owners offers the record company virtually no benefit in return. I don't buy very many CD's. I recently purchased The Pick of Destiny by Tenacious D. I purchased this for three reasons: A.I like the band and I want them to make more music. B.By successful record sales, A will be more likely C.It was not $18...more like $14. Inside the CD was a loose piece of paper with a note something to the effect of: enter this code XXXXXXXX at www.somewebaddy.com and get an exclusive track.

westernorbit, Dec 05 2006

Copyright © Barry Nalebuff & Ian Ayres