WhyNot?

Air passengers encased in foam

Category:
Responses: 6 (2 in support, 0 neutral, 4 in opposition)
Number of views: 823
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Weak WeakYour Rating:

This may be a lot of old cobblers but could it be possible to fit commercial airliners with a "last resort" system whereby a series of aerosols under the floor fill the cabin with quick drying foam that will completely encase the passengers?

The foam would not only absorb impact but it would allow the body to move around just enough to minimise internal injuries. The foam would also need to allow people to breath (or perhaps they have to put on breathing masks first)

Horribly claustrophobic, I know, but better than certain death.

What level of impact could such a foam survive?

Would the pilots have to sacrifice themselves (making sure the plane hurtles into a forest and not a busy city street)?

Whataloadof, Jan 15 2007

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Other ideas in category ():

Im not an architect but, (1 votes) Average
question (1 votes) Average
Brake Light Addition (2 votes) Average
Wind Funnel for Green Energy (1 votes) Average
heavy cars(not realy) (2 votes) Average
garage door senser (1 votes) Average
time and gravity theory (2 votes) Average
universal language (1 votes) Average
Upgrade Why Not? (1 votes) Average
earth sun glasses (1 votes) Average
close to sun studys. (1 votes) Average
Ziploc chip bags (107 votes) Very strong
helium battery (3 votes) Average
walk through walls (2 votes) Average
Auto Paper Roll (1 votes) Average
TV Controller,Half Mute Button (2 votes) Average
cold lights? or darks (1 votes) Average
APPLIANCE FINDER (3 votes) Average
BRING YOUR BAG (2 votes) Average
Pre-Paid Food Stamps (1 votes) Average
seeing atoms (1 votes) Average
portable gaming (1 votes) Average
High presure low pressure (1 votes) Average
TV Remote (3 votes) Average
individual air generator (2 votes) Average
GIVE IT BACK!!!!! (2 votes) Average
wheel chair door (3 votes) Average
exam for photo lab techs (1 votes) Average
drag n flight (1 votes) Average
Music Website idea (2 votes) Average
breaking a magnetic field (1 votes) Average
show me the money (2 votes) Average
Robber Knock Out Gas (3 votes) Average
Hygienic public arm rest (1 votes) Average
photochromic contact lenses (3 votes) Average
Mirror on Computer Screen (10 votes) Strong
LED GLASS (1 votes) Average
read to me (1 votes) Average
knock knock (1 votes) Average
throw a pic (2 votes) Average
tired (3 votes) Weak
lets chat (4 votes) Average
Land route India to Colombo (1 votes) Average
Traffic Light Communication (1 votes) Average
Personal Home Energy Monitor (8 votes) Strong
Singular home light source. (2 votes) Average
Perpetual Pendulum (1 votes) Average
SOLAR WINDTURBINES (6 votes) Weak
Strollcycle (1 votes) Average
A breath of fresh air (2 votes) Average
Climate Smart Appliances (1 votes) Average
Windmills on building roofs (3 votes) Average
An enjoyable rail experience (2 votes) Average
Electricity from gyms (2 votes) Average
REMOTE FINDER SWITCH (2 votes) Average
Spectacle / KeyChain Locaters (2 votes) Average
Green Gyms (8 votes) Strong
SOLAR UMBRELLA (5 votes) Average
Washer n' Dryer in one (16 votes) Very strong
E-trains (1 votes) Average
entropy (1 votes) Average
Tingle - Deo (1 votes) Average
CreditCard Operated Laundrymat (4 votes) Average
Fridge door open alert (3 votes) Average
CELL PHONE PTT (2 votes) Average
Relationship Status Wrist Band (31 votes) Very strong
Instant Witness (2 votes) Average
Fold Down Padded Shower Seat (2 votes) Average
Little People Lift (2 votes) Average
shipment tracking sms (2 votes) Average
Integrity in financial markets (1 votes) Average
Wasted (4 votes) Average
Grocery Store Congestion Prici (1 votes) Average
Paying for a free press (3 votes) Weak
car dehumidifier (3 votes) Average
New Dive Computer (2 votes) Average
flashing center brake light (1 votes) Average
What is the Unspoken Truth (3 votes) Average
Higher Education Equivalency (2 votes) Average
Aire Surfing (3 votes) Average
Skyscraper escape flumes (4 votes) Average
Reinvent the Automat!!! (2 votes) Average
why this site fails, sorry (7 votes) Average
Power up your life! A power so (3 votes) Average
Self Check Lotto Machine (1 votes) Average
the future of CDs!! (4 votes) Average
Tv,The way is used to be (1 votes) Average
a simple idea for whynot (1 votes) Average
Email when Credit Card Used (4 votes) Average
Speed control in vehicle (2 votes) Average
Security for your wallet (2 votes) Average
Mobile cellphone charger (1 votes) Average
BATTERY BAYS (4 votes) Average
GSM-AUTO control (1 votes) Average
Energy & time saving Elevator (1 votes) Average
U turn sign prevents accidents (1 votes) Average
Bring back the SICKLE MOWER (1 votes) Average
Better Emergency Sirens (2 votes) Average
New Mobile form factor (3 votes) Average
Radio (2 votes) Average
turn off your tv (6 votes) Average
Suggestion For This Site (2 votes) Average
Video That Sends Text Messages (2 votes) Average
Working Women (5 votes) Weak
Speed Brakers .....CHARGE!!! (1 votes) Average
take out delivery menu website (8 votes) Strong
Paid per minutes computers (2 votes) Average
Low frequency learning (1 votes) Average
modern typewriters (3 votes) Average
Economic Crisis (1 votes) Average
Abortion Compromise (6 votes) Weak
Break resistant wine glasses (4 votes) Weak
CASTING WEBSITE (5 votes) Strong
LED BULBS (3 votes) Average
Wing wheels (1 votes) Average
quick solution to gas problem (1 votes) Average
big version of iPhone (1 votes) Average
apple iGame (1 votes) Average
Unwanted Pet Population (2 votes) Average
Satellite mute (2 votes) Average
Elevator Occupancy Sensor (4 votes) Average
Wireless Waitress (3 votes) Average
Refridgerator door Remote (4 votes) Average
Hotel and Traveler Web 2.0 (1 votes) Average
program/database for moviefile (2 votes) Average
Fun Dolls for Dogs (2 votes) Average
Wrap-a-Tombstone (3 votes) Weak
Car pillow (2 votes) Average
Perpetual motor machines (3 votes) Weak
Towel/Shower curtain (3 votes) Weak
shoes (1 votes) Average
Sand shoes (2 votes) Average
For smokers at the airport (4 votes) Average
clearing landmines (3 votes) Average
Electronic Parking Meter (2 votes) Average
Birth Control for Pets (4 votes) Average
Ignition Start (1 votes) Average
Space saving super market (3 votes) Average
business card reader (2 votes) Average
Bookmark (3 votes) Average
Cafexpress (2 votes) Average
contact lens change indicator (10 votes) Strong
Voice it (4 votes) Average
Conscience Store (1 votes) Average
Record cell phone converstions (1 votes) Average
ROLL ACTED BEARING (1 votes) Average
Eliminate Day-light Savings (5 votes) Average
Daily Wikipedia (4 votes) Average
Airplane Book Exchange (3 votes) Average
New Alternative to Gasoline? (3 votes) Average
Advertising Toilet Roll (1 votes) Average
TV WITH PIC BLANK SWITCH (6 votes) Average
best way to regain our fossils (2 votes) Average
Kid-Proof TV "On/Off" Covers (3 votes) Weak
A robot that can play a guitar (1 votes) Average
Parachute Alternative? (2 votes) Average
solar power BBQ grill (2 votes) Average
Fuel Efficiency Lanes (7 votes) Average
Small portable water filters (1 votes) Average
Glutinous rice paper (42 votes) Very strong
id recognition system thru eye (3 votes) Average
Hydrogen Tank Car A.C (2 votes) Average
FOREST FIRE ALERTER (1 votes) Average
Gas Nozzle Holder (4 votes) Average
21ST Century Greetings (1 votes) Average
Sequential Brake Light System (1 votes) Average
Heat resistant make-up bag (3 votes) Average
silent click mouse (2 votes) Average
BASKET CAR (4 votes) Weak
AIDS TAX (5 votes) Weak
Luxury car lease swaps (2 votes) Average
ideas for t.v. or web (2 votes) Average
Miniature wiper blades glasses (2 votes) Average
AERODYNAMIC AIRSHIP (2 votes) Average
Real Time Luggage Insurance (14 votes) Very strong
green food packets (7 votes) Strong
Stirling engine refrigerator (3 votes) Average
Robot Helper (2 votes) Average
College/grad school PhysEd (1 votes) Average
The Next Gen water bottles (2 votes) Average
Integrated camera in backpack (3 votes) Average
Remote control for your shower (3 votes) Average
Meals - Indian professionals (2 votes) Average
post swim soap (1 votes) Average
cereal box spouts (7 votes) Strong
Green Remedy for Clogged Drain (1 votes) Average
Email to International AirMail (1 votes) Average
Leasing computers (2 votes) Average
Shoe lace tying machine (1 votes) Average
Stop killing your plants (3 votes) Average
Funny/Flexible Cell Ring Tone (1 votes) Average
Young Artists Syndicate (1 votes) Average
Payment Option at the Gas Pump (5 votes) Average
A la Carte Airline Meals (5 votes) Average
RolePay - Career Mgmt Software (2 votes) Average
G Foreman Grill Improvement (6 votes) Average
Steering wheel alcohol tester (1 votes) Average
Bra cup protection (2 votes) Average
eMentoring - Reducing AIDS (4 votes) Average
Biodegradable Running Warm Up (4 votes) Weak
self powered generator (2 votes) Average
Stairmaster Generator (2 votes) Average
Mobile Remittances (1 votes) Average
THERMOCOLE HELMETS (3 votes) Weak
ziploc bags with holes (6 votes) Average
PARKING LOT MMS (2 votes) Average
CB ECHOLINK (2 votes) Average
Appliances (4 votes) Average
JAMMER INDICATOR (1 votes) Average
REMOTE FOR A PROJECTION TV (1 votes) Average
QUICK AIDS TEST KIT (2 votes) Average
LCD MONITORS ON HIRE (1 votes) Average
Reading while waiting (2 votes) Average
Laptop harness (6 votes) Average
SLAVE POWER FOR SHIPS (1 votes) Average
Buy with Tv remote (1 votes) Average
Polarized Contact Lenses (9 votes) Strong
God (2 votes) Average
cars (3 votes) Weak
RFID FILE LOCK (1 votes) Average
SOUP CUBES (1 votes) Average
Lets have a baby.com (8 votes) Strong
YOUTUBE THEATRES (2 votes) Average
VHS-C TAPE RECORDERS (1 votes) Average
A new dish washer (2 votes) Average
WC ANTISEPTIC SPARYS (1 votes) Average
RFID KID BANDS (1 votes) Average
RFID SCHOOL BAGS (3 votes) Weak
CLOTHESLINE CLIP (2 votes) Average
PICTURE IN REMOTE (1 votes) Average
TV REMOTE FOR THE AGED (1 votes) Average
HELMET BAGS (2 votes) Average
Cell Phone scramblers for cars (1 votes) Average
Bush aaaaaaaaaaaaaaah (4 votes) Weak
SOLAR TENTS (1 votes) Average
Gas Pump Vending (2 votes) Average
BUBBLE SONG STICK (1 votes) Average
Incr.effi.for vechicle pressur (1 votes) Average
cellphone alarm(siren) (1 votes) Average
GAT CARDS (2 votes) Average
Guitar Tuning (6 votes) Strong
CELL PHONE GENERATORS (4 votes) Weak
ORGANIC KITCHEN GARDEN (3 votes) Average
Recycle EVERYTHING! (2 votes) Average
RFID SHOES (1 votes) Average
READY MADE DRINK (PET) (1 votes) Average
Peeling fruit is annoying... (3 votes) Average
CYBER RESTAURANTS (2 votes) Average
PEN AEROSOLS (1 votes) Average
fair trade sailing cargo (2 votes) Average
FACE ID CARD (1 votes) Average
GPV COMBO (1 votes) Average
RFID TIE PINS (4 votes) Weak
Doorbrella (1 votes) Average
Buy as much as you like (4 votes) Weak
Flavor patches for dieters (1 votes) Average
AUTOMATIC FOOD SERVERS (2 votes) Average
PACKET SOS (1 votes) Average
Practical method to EDIT Posts (12 votes) Very strong
VIRUSNET (2 votes) Average
OIL SPILL RECOVERY (1 votes) Average
tourist speech prompt (1 votes) Average
A 4th Traffic Light (4 votes) Weak
ELEVATOR - AUTO/MECHANICAL (1 votes) Average
ROAD GENERATORS (3 votes) Weak
recording a class for later (4 votes) Average
ELEVATORS FOR THE AGED (1 votes) Average
DIGITAL FILM THEATRES (1 votes) Average
Sound monitor for Cars (2 votes) Average
electronic grade notification (13 votes) Very strong
rfid fridge trays (5 votes) Average
fishing hook electro shocker (1 votes) Average
mirkamali (7 votes) Weak
Pedaling Prisoners (5 votes) Weak
Flying car (3 votes) Average
Drug tests for athlete tirades (1 votes) Average
Hand dryer -- FOR WHOLE BODY (11 votes) Strong
Hotels:In room internationalTV (1 votes) Average
Image processing (2 votes) Average
test (2 votes) Average
Cancellation of User Account (5 votes) Strong
Knowing my balance - ATM (3 votes) Average
Toiletry bag modification (3 votes) Average
Ziploc Cracker Sleeves... (3 votes) Average
Engagement Rings for Men (5 votes) Average
Customized Newspaper Section (1 votes) Average
New Brake Light (0 votes) Very weak
Personal firewall in cell phon (1 votes) Average
Hand-Held Trackball (4 votes) Average
stereo mini-jack in on planes (2 votes) Average
Aircraft Claustrophobia (1 votes) Average
Multi credit card (4 votes) Average
call ring mutes the player (2 votes) Average
left click finger scanner (1 votes) Average
<b>Save hundreds on vet bills< (3 votes) Average
automatic dishwasher (2 votes) Average
Portable Washing Machine (2 votes) Average
reduce drunk driving (4 votes) Weak
Automobil collision prevention (3 votes) Weak
Clothing rental at destination (6 votes) Average
Self Draining Tuna Can (12 votes) Average
TrulyAmerica Needs Your Help (2 votes) Average
The Window Slide (12 votes) Strong
Excerise bike for video games (5 votes) Average
An e-mailing key (5 votes) Average
Rent-a-theater (6 votes) Average
Walker of lifting wheel (1 votes) Average
Basketball 4-Point Line (6 votes) Weak
Visual Audio Exercise Device (4 votes) Average
Dictate a Text Message (7 votes) Strong
KeyPad Pen (4 votes) Average
solid light (0 votes) Very weak
Human Gerbil Wheel (3 votes) Average
New Idea for Movie tickets (4 votes) Average
Page button on a TV (21 votes) Very strong
Cereal Marshmallows (3 votes) Average
Cell Phone Conference Bridge (1 votes) Average
Speak Easy - Noist Cell Phone! (1 votes) Average
Claw to remove Broom Dust (3 votes) Weak
Ball bag attached to Hoop pole (1 votes) Average
Personal Alarm Clock Bracelet (3 votes) Average
Baby food jar rack (1 votes) Average
Windsurfing + Snowboarding (3 votes) Average
Airport baggage area (1 votes) Average
MPG tax/subsidy (3 votes) Weak
StarvingArtist+StarvingVendor (2 votes) Average
WhyNot for Kids (4 votes) Average
Pre-order Coffee (2 votes) Average
Solving the hairy issue (5 votes) Weak
Personal Catcher (1 votes) Average
remote locator (2 votes) Average
The Photographed World (3 votes) Average
Baseball Contrail (1 votes) Average
High-End Coffee Delivery in CT (4 votes) Weak
Do not disturb for air travel (16 votes) Very strong
Pit Stops (2 votes) Average
Conversational Emergency (2 votes) Average
Where have I parked (1 votes) Average
Jacket warmers (2 votes) Average
Children/Elderly Nonprofit (2 votes) Average
Streaking newsprint (2 votes) Average
Media Delivery (2 votes) Average
yale public transport solution (2 votes) Average
Supermarket in the Mall (5 votes) Strong
Iron/Starch Combo (4 votes) Average
Dinner Cart at SOM (8 votes) Strong
Scented pants? (2 votes) Average
Ready to use squash balls (2 votes) Average
Hangover Helper (2 votes) Average
Cell Phone Booth (2 votes) Average
Lunch suggesting cell phone (5 votes) Strong
jet lag cure (5 votes) Average
Shaving-Cream Qty Indicator (10 votes) Strong
Cooling Blanket (8 votes) Strong
In-flight Massage (5 votes) Strong
Automatic rolling cart (1 votes) Average
Cell Phone Away Message (2 votes) Average
No more lines at the carts.... (2 votes) Average
Immigration Status Visual Trac (5 votes) Average
No more lines at the carts.... (1 votes) Average
Bus tracker (2 votes) Average
Automatic headlight dim (6 votes) Strong
Interests website (3 votes) Average
Scenic MapQuest Site (8 votes) Strong
Flexible Cable TV plan (5 votes) Average
Air passengers encased in foam (6 votes) Weak
Democratized traffic patrol (7 votes) Average
bluetooth signboard (2 votes) Average
Bluetooth Advertiser (2 votes) Average
greenhouse (2 votes) Average
QuickData Financial Software (2 votes) Average
Edison (1 votes) Average
better brake pads (2 votes) Average
edible tape (2 votes) Average
Cell phone ring configurator (5 votes) Average
Private eqity (1 votes) Average
Fraudsters (1 votes) Average
Fraudsters (2 votes) Average
Corporate governance (1 votes) Average
Scholarships (1 votes) Average
Employee compensation option (1 votes) Average
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

Although passengers might survive a crash, can you imagine what it might be like encased in foam and trapped in a fuselage in the middle of a forest or desert or floating in the ocean hundreds of miles from civilization? Perhaps cyanide filled dentures might be useful there.

sand, Jan 15 2007

According to statistics I've seen, more people die in burning planes on the ground because they can't get out in time than are killed during the crashes. The foam would obviously compound this problem.

Dwane Anderson, Jan 15 2007

Hmm, this sounds a bit over the top. I would perfer to have an old fashion parachute that would separate from the wings, and the rest of the fuselage, and glide gently down to earth. Being encased in aerosol foam with 15000 gallons of jet fuel igniting around me does not sound like a way I would perfer to die.

bkeene12, Jan 15 2007

The ideal shock absorber would be to fill the cabin with water and give the passengers breathing apparatus. Unfortunately this would make the plane so heavy it could never fly.

sand, Jan 16 2007

Interesting idea but remember the plane is traveling at 500?? mph. So the instant seat 5B hits earth (and slows to 0 mph rather quickly), right behind are seat rows 6 through 27, two lavatories and a tail section that are still traveling at 500 mph (i.e. 5B and 27B and all in between will kiss in less than 1/7 of a second). All of them will be joining 5B in 4B's seat back. Foam inside a plane will not stop the inertia. Alternatively, we could fill the earth with foam - that would allow a crashing plane to decelerate at a survivable rate. Until we do that, I'll go for the parachute bkeene12 recommended.

rdy4trvl, Jan 17 2007

What you're talking about here sounds more like the need for a system to deploy airbags that stay inflated until the plane quits moving. Seems great as long as the fuselage remains intact. Pretty much useless otherwise.

Hyenuf, Jan 19 2007

Whataloadof: Excellent idea.
The foam already exists on most aircraft, it exists as the seats we sit in. If the seats were contoured to our bodies and the seat in front of us matched our contour, then the seats just need to slide together to encase us in foam. If the aircraft computer/sensor package detected an impending catastrophic accident, the seats could slam together, jetison from the plane, and deploy a ballistic parachute to allow most passengers to survive.

The foam system may not be suitable in all situations, however, computers and sensors are commonly utilized for making such decisions. Airbags in automobiles are typical. Only under specific circumstances do airbags deploy.

Also, the foam does not necessarily need to be a solid. Aerogel is a lightweight compound that resists deformation, but it certainly can be deformed easily. How many G's can be experienced and survive with the right density of material? There is so much that is unknown about this problem that it we can only come up with ideas for what might work, or what possibly should be considered.

A professional skydiver jumped at 3,000 feet AGL and both chutes failed to open. With a terminal velocity of about 150 mph, the skydiver landed flat on his back on newly layed sod. After a short time the skydiver was conscious and aware, but was unable to move having broken many of the bones in his body. He walked out of the hospital after 6 months and returned to skydiving. With some assistance, even catastrophic accidents may be survivable by many, though probably not all.

Excellent Idea