WhyNot?

Removable Heel Shoes

Category: Retail
Responses: 42 (32 in support, 4 neutral, 6 in opposition)
Number of views: 10596
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Very strong Very strongYour Rating:

Women often complain about the discomfort of high-heeled shoes. Additionally, heeled shoes are not an option if one is recovering from an ankle or other lower-extremity injury. To remediate this, many women will opt to wear sneakers or flats as they walk to work or other destinations. Usually, this looks unattractive with a suit or nice business clothing. Another drawback of wearing comfortable shoes instead of heeled-shoes is that the pair of shoes with heels needs to be carried in a separate bag (no one wants to carry more while commuting than they have to).

As a solution, I propose removable heel shoes. An attractive shoe could be developed where the heel can snap or screw into the bottom. When walking is necessary, the heels of the shoes can be removed and thrown into a purse. A woman then has instant, comfortable flats. Subsequently, when one reaches the target destination, the heels can be screwed or snapped back into place (it must be stable) and one can look appropriate with business attire. This solves the comfort issue and carrying issue as the heels of a shoe can easily fit into a purse rather than carrying a separate bag.

barrekr, Jan 23 2007

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Ziploc chip bags (104 votes) Very strong
Better Brake Light (446 votes) Very strong
Attachment Notation (137 votes) Very strong
Airport charity (148 votes) Very strong
Audio-in Jacks in Cars (177 votes) Very strong
Ending the war on drugs (247 votes) Very strong
Cable TV (93 votes) Very strong
Glutinous rice paper (42 votes) Very strong
General Use EZ-Pass (48 votes) Very strong
GPS and Digital Photos (173 votes) Very strong

Other ideas in category (Retail):

Comments from other members:

Add your comment

Sounds promising. Though I don't have too much experience wearing high-heeled shows, regular shoes hurt my feet, so I can't imagine how painful high-heeled shoes must be.

josh52078, Jan 23 2007

As idea pretty good - I've been thinking about it for years - but I'm afraid that it's also pretty impossbile to engineer such shoes (I don't know how much you know about manufacturing or designing high heel shoes, I only have experience with the way designers work at Valentino - and so far it doesn't seem that there is a sole that can give you the support and stability needed that a high heel needs and that is yet flexible enough to change form into a low- or no-heel shoe).

yep, Jan 23 2007

I think you hit on a big problem that many women face. My fiancee, who I know isn't alone, is always talking about how sore her feet are walking home from work. There's an interesting article I had read (below) that discusses an invention along the lines you are suggesting, but with a foldaway high heel.

http://edition.cnn.com/2004/TECH/09/02/ella.kilgour/

MScherzer, Jan 23 2007

There is certainly a need for convertible shoes. However, I'm not sure how practical this would be. For example, there would have to be rubber or some scuffable surface added to the bottom of the shoe once the heel is removed. There is no rational reason behind wearing heels anyway, other than they are attractive. Therefore, adding a screw-post and a chunk of rubber to the back of something intended for style could be challenging.

DPGlass, Jan 23 2007

This sounds like a really good idea, but it would seem to fight an uphill battle against those who see this as unfashionable. There is definitely a need for a product like this, but I'm not so sure that many women would be willing to sacrifice the allure of high fashion. Might be like the pants that zip-off to become shorts.

jcfreedman, Jan 23 2007

I think this is a great idea and would be a very popular product if it could be done fashionably. I was sorry to hear yep's comment but I hope that there is some way this could be done that hasn't been thought of yet. Perhaps it wouldn't work for a really high heel but maybe for a lower heal that is still business appropriate it would work.

em79, Jan 23 2007

My wife would love this. She almost always carries two pairs of shoes while going to/from work. I imagine it will be difficult to combine comfort with style, however.

amorabdc, Jan 23 2007

I think it is an excellent idea. There is a huge market for it.

Vva5, Jan 24 2007

Brilliant! I've often wished I could remove the heels on my shoes or add them on as need be.

els45, Jan 24 2007

I would love it if my wife could do this so we could walk to dinner and she could wear "going out" shoes.

weg, Jan 24 2007

I think the concept is good. Since this has to be aesthetically pleasing, I was thinking of a swivel heel (one that would become part of the sole of the shoe) instead of a heel that would completely detach.

ubaheti, Jan 24 2007

A snap off exchangeable heel for women's shoes was actually invented and shown on Australia's ABC "New Inventors" show back in 2003 or 4. The clever part of the invention was the twist and snap in lock system.

whoozhe, Feb 20 2007

Just a hinge, and you can walk with the stem in either position. However, this is a practical solution for an impractical practice (high heels) so I'm not sure if it will make "sense" to the high-heeled consumer.

wizard61, Mar 30 2007

Good idea, but aren't high-heeled shoes usually somewhat arched? How would you compensate for this and make them both flat and heeled?

supg, May 26 2007

Here is my idea.

Instead of a snap off heel, what you do is create a mold that will take the base of the shoe, heel and all in the flat position and then a rubber sole to the whole device which is flat.

The heel will enter the base unit at about a 30 to 40 degree angle.

You will end up being 2 inches off the ground, but since most people shrink an inch at work anyway the net result is 1 inch taller:)

hydrogenauto, May 31 2007

How about actually making it like the radio anthena of high end cars. You push a button and it comes out. You can even adjust the height by stopping it before it totally comes out.

xkuntay, Jan 18 2009

This idea is near ready to hit the stores ;)

ChrisA, Sep 15 2009