WhyNot?

Eliminate the Penny!

Category: Public
Responses: 42 (32 in support, 1 neutral, 9 in opposition)
Number of views: 4427
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Very strong Very strongYour Rating:

Pennies have become extremely useless in that they have so little purchasing power and require significant cost to continually move them around. Therefore, the penny should be eliminated.

bigmac, Jan 23 2007

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Better Brake Light (466 votes) Very strong
Ending the war on drugs (260 votes) Very strong
Audio-in Jacks in Cars (186 votes) Very strong
This concept is great! (143 votes) Very strong
Elevator DeSelect (167 votes) Very strong
Aerial pictures in flight (226 votes) Very strong
like IMDB but for government (113 votes) Very strong
Airport charity (150 votes) Very strong
Refrigerator (121 votes) Very strong
Ziploc chip bags (107 votes) Very strong

Other ideas in category (Public):

TOUCH SCREEN FOR ELEVATOR (1 votes) Average
RFID CAR Registration (10 votes) Weak
Drug house remover (17 votes) Very weak
Your own personal ZIP code (2 votes) Average
Skyscraper safety chutes (8 votes) Average
Police taxis (7 votes) Average
Elevator 'Door Open' Buttons (2 votes) Average
Elevator DeSelect (167 votes) Very strong
Financial Incompetency (8 votes) Weak
Government Spending Cut Idea (1 votes) Average
How about zero toll booths (14 votes) Weak
Piracy bait (2 votes) Average
Eliminate the Penny! (42 votes) Very strong
Tower of Babel for Gangs (2 votes) Average
Public Service Inventions (1 votes) Average
Save the Lanes (1 votes) Average
Civil conscription (3 votes) Average
Debit System for Parking Meter (5 votes) Average
Buy custom newsreader voices? (1 votes) Average
Smart elevators (4 votes) Average
Single Global Currency (12 votes) Very weak
Kid Friendly Bathrooms (3 votes) Average
Public Transportation Switch (2 votes) Average
Government Ebay (5 votes) Strong
Library Books - New Policy (9 votes) Average
Daylight Savings Time Reform (3 votes) Weak
free gas during evacuation (2 votes) Average
burglar-proof cash register (3 votes) Weak
bad driver hotline (5 votes) Weak
Another 9-11 (9 votes) Very weak
Pay-to-Cut. (7 votes) Average
free train power (6 votes) Average
Parking bill instead of fine (4 votes) Weak
Siren Alert traffic Lights (3 votes) Weak
anti-trust via jumbo taxes (2 votes) Average
Energy Saving Street Lights (3 votes) Average
A lite version of 9-1-1 calls (3 votes) Average
Red paint that doesn't fade (2 votes) Average
Put Cockroaches On Mars (7 votes) Average
Auto Doors for Pub Bathrooms (2 votes) Average
me for president ! (2 votes) Average
National Water Balancing (3 votes) Average
save billions of dollars (5 votes) Weak
Restroom Pantyhose Dispensers (2 votes) Average
cure-all STD's (4 votes) Average
Fake Baghdad (5 votes) Weak
Airplane Ejection Modules (6 votes) Weak
No more metro cards (9 votes) Strong
New Airport Metal Detectors (2 votes) Average
Metal detector flashlight (2 votes) Average
Baby Isolator (4 votes) Average
Voluntary inner prison (2 votes) Average
Privatized Libraries (6 votes) Weak
Tax Energy - Not Income (4 votes) Weak
Traceable Spray Paint Graffiti (3 votes) Weak
Elevator Floor Number Undo (7 votes) Strong
A crook or a banditt? (4 votes) Average
Movie Seats Trash Bin (4 votes) Average
passports (5 votes) Average
Solution Radio (1 votes) Average
Easy Change (3 votes) Average
QMatic tokens (1 votes) Average
Ground Based (1 votes) Average
Triangular escalator system (2 votes) Average
internet on planes... (1 votes) Average
Video billboards (5 votes) Weak
credit cards (2 votes) Average
credit cards (1 votes) Average
Ending 2X-a-year time shifting (5 votes) Average
BusQuest (5 votes) Strong
Cancel Elevator Button (6 votes) Strong
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

But then how would anyone put their two cents in?

wahoo, Jan 23 2007

Hell yeah! And make our bills different colors. And maybe add a picture of Will Ferrel on a bill. Or a penguin.

ToTheLeft, Jan 23 2007

I agree!

joezeng, Jan 23 2007

Yep, and its pretty darn obvious, too... I do not know why we have not already done it, but I guess we just hate change. (Sorry)

wizard1961, Apr 25 2007

Rather than eliminate the penny, why not back our money with something of real substance(i.e.) putting us back on the gold standard. Money would actually be worth something and inflation would be greatly reduced as there is a finite supply of gold. A penny would then have some "real" value.

tommy1mn, Apr 25 2007

I currently have 55,000 pennies. Haven't spent one in years. They make an impression on the grandkids when you dump 'em out on the floor & tell the kids to start counting. Someday I'll take the pennies to the bank and buy myself something cool.

Hyenuf, Apr 26 2007

And the nickel, too! And replace the quarter with a 20¢ piece ($.2) so we could simply drop a digit in money transactions.

traal, May 09 2007

You'll need a 50-years notice at the least

SonnyResetti, May 18 2007

Pennies are worth more if you melt them down and make jewelery. 5 pennies can be made into a $10.00 pair of earings.....

SlickWilly, Jun 12 2007

Several times in the past the penny was to be gotten rid of but the "People from Illinois" put a stop to the idea because of Lincoln's pic and Illinois is the birth place of him.

Cut a penny into now and you will see it is NOT copper but just clad and has been for several years.

CSM, Jun 27 2007

And why not get rid of penny loafers at the same time?

paul1732, Jul 13 2007

I come from one of the numerous other countries which has already done this. It's a good idea. In most currency systems the value of coins and notes tends to go up by a factor of about x3 per step. And inflation -- on a very rough long term average -- tends to devalue money by a factor of x3 in about 25 ~ 30 years. So it makes sense to eliminate the smallest coin, and change the smallest bill into a coin, about once every 25 ~ 30 years.

@tommy1mn:We could argue about the gold standard for hours, but let's not. Its biggest problem is something that you almost bring out then: there is a limited supply of gold. However, the total value of the economy continues to increase not just due to inflation but in real terms, because of population increase, technological advances, and the accumulation of real wealth which outpaces depreciation. Thus having a finite amount of money to represent all that wealth causes deflation where the value of the money continuously increases.

Why is that a problem? Well, for one thing it was the chief cause of the Great Depression, and also of grinding poverty for workers at the beginning of the Industrial Revolution. In technical terms, inflation is a negative feedback system which (usually) tends to put a check on the pressures causing inflation, but deflation is a positive feedback system in which a little deflation tends to cause even more until it spirals out of control. Inflation is a minor nuisance. Deflation can be disastrous.

bugmenot, Aug 03 2007

historical precedent has found it more more useful to just move the decimal point on the dollars. Today, there's not really anything a nickle can buy either. So if all-at once a penny was worth ten-cents and a nickle could buy a Coke, we'd all be happy.

Of course the initial switchover would be really inflationary, but with the government printing money like it doesn't have any, probably the 'blip' would be unnoticed.

hrench, Nov 28 2007

Ban the penny as soon as possible - Coz it would becomea collector's item in a couple of years - you could buy a copper penny on ebay for a dollar.

pepindia007, Aug 07 2008

Our current currency is too complicated and outdated:

Coins: penny, nickel, dime, quarter, 0.50, 1Bills: 1, 2, 5, 10, 20, 50, 100

My proposal is to eliminate the penny, dollar bill, and any units that are so rare they're more novelties than serious money:

Coins: nickel, dime, quarter, 1Bills: 5, 10, 20, 50, 100

IMHO, no coin should be minted that is worth more than its own face value. When it's illegal to melt down pennies for recycling _because they're worth more melted down than as money_, you know something's wrong.

flguy1980, Jan 28 2009

A penny saved is a penny earned.

That said, I will admit to tossing my fair share of pennies or not picking up a penny that the cashier drops while handing me my change.

However, elimination of the penny inherently poses many problems. For example, everything that used to cost $0.01, $0.02, $0.03, or $0.04 would now have to cost a nickel.

I believe a better solution would be to make making pennies cheaper. Mint pennies from plastic. There are significant advantages making money made of plastic compared to traditional paper and metal. Just google it.

kbong, Jun 19 2009