WhyNot?

Cell phone signal jammers

Category: Education
Responses: 8 (4 in support, 0 neutral, 4 in opposition)
Number of views: 1880
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Average AverageYour Rating:

Classrooms should have a cell phone signal blocker installed. There is no good reason not to have this today. The technology is available and affordable. A switch to turn the blocker off could be installed on the Professor's podium.

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Other ideas in category (Education):

An improved driving test (1 votes) Average
DORM ROOM PREVIEW (2 votes) Average
Customized Travel Guides (2 votes) Average
Watch and Learn (2 votes) Average
shuufabet revised (4 votes) Average
large-scale textbk review web (3 votes) Average
Job training in High School (5 votes) Average
Wash your mouth out with soap (5 votes) Average
Plagiarism (2 votes) Average
no drop out policy (2 votes) Average
fold-up ebook (3 votes) Average
School-Specific PDA (4 votes) Average
Graduate School Nap Time (6 votes) Strong
Radical Public Ed Proposal (2 votes) Average
Shuufabet/truly phonetic (1 votes) Average
Timer in Kid's room (3 votes) Average
Reading illegal=literacy (5 votes) Weak
Cheating 1 (8 votes) Very weak
virtual crowds raise awareness (3 votes) Average
Professor Zapper!!! (9 votes) Strong
Membership (2 votes) Average
Learn to edit Wikipedia (1 votes) Average
Why Not Higher Ed Diploma? (1 votes) Average
Test (1 votes) Average
Online GED (2 votes) Average
Textbook tablet (2 votes) Average
Capitalist College (13 votes) Strong
Learn how to Learn (4 votes) Average
moderate the teachers (8 votes) Weak
public audio university (11 votes) Strong
Credibility Database (3 votes) Average
SAT scores ~ tutor pay (4 votes) Average
Sim Project Management (3 votes) Average
question rating buzzer (21 votes) Average
Credit Education (3 votes) Average
Mandatory Phys-Ed for MBAs (19 votes) Strong
Cell phone signal jammers (8 votes) Average
Idea/Solution Communities (1 votes) Average
Wiki Notes (1 votes) Average
Out of Africa (2 votes) Average
Yale SOM + iTunes (19 votes) Very strong
0.5 Credit Internship Assignme (6 votes) Average
Attrcating students (2 votes) Average
Lowering debt of best students (7 votes) Weak
Submitting assignments (4 votes) Weak
Subtraction BEFORE Addition (11 votes) Strong
Color Graphing Calculators (4 votes) Average
Flexible textbooks (3 votes) Average
Sound Proof (3 votes) Average
Honest (3 votes) Weak
School-Issued PDAs (2 votes) Average
Math-Leading or misleading us? (3 votes) Weak
DLS-C COMLAB (1 votes) Average
Wikipedia RSS Feeds (4 votes) Average
Cheating 2 (5 votes) Weak
Economics is ... ? (2 votes) Average
Foreign Expressions (2 votes) Average
Commuter Naps (4 votes) Average
Stand-up Comedy in line (5 votes) Average
N. Ireland solution? (4 votes) Average
Surplus paper (3 votes) Average
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

YES. This would be great. The only problem that would arise is when a person is expecting a very important phone call, like a wife going into labor -- in that case, people don't have the option of being reachable.

Adrienne Ronai, Jan 23 2007

The emergency scenario is why I suggested a switch to turn the blocker off.

I understand, but turning the blocker off then allows EVERYONE'S phone to ring during class, and we've seen what happens in a class of 70 people. Further, people might get accustomed to not having to turn off their phones, so that when the blocker isn't on, there might be even more rings. Also, with a class of 70 people, I'd guess that at least once a week someone would need the blocker turned off (think of all the people waiting to hear about job offers who are too anxious to wait for lunch), which defeats the purpose of the blocker. It would be interesting if the blocker could spare individual phones that request cell phone service and have instructor permission, so the rest of the class still doesn't have service. Or better yet would be a device that could still allow service, but would not allow phones to make ring sounds (i.e. switch all phones in the area to the "vibrate" function automatically).

Adrienne Ronai, Jan 23 2007

I like this idea. It sounds simple to implement, addresses a widespread need, and in my opinion, its benefits seem to far outweigh its weaknesses. Nice job.

Kristen Silvi, Jan 23 2007

I think this is a great idea that can apply to other scenarios as well- having worked in a theater, even after the "turn your cell phone off" announcement had been made, phones would continue to ring. I wonder if for important "people"- those doctors who might receive emergency calls, husbands with pregnant wives, MBA's with job offers there were a way to override for just one cell phone rather than shut off the whole blocking system.

med, Jan 24 2007

This idea is already being worked on by theaters, mainly in cooperation with paint companies. I recall reading about a type of paint which successfully blocked cell phone signals, but the theater group decided not to deploy it. Their reasoning? Liability. People have a reasonable expectation to have access to their cell phone in case of emergency. There are some remote scenarios where people trapped in a theater would need to use their cell phones to contact emergency services, reference the Moscow theater hostage crisis of 2002. This type of liability also applies to schools, as any sort of Columbine scenario makes obvious.

Personally, I just bring a toy water gun to the theater and "shoot" people in the backs of their heads when they use their cell phone. Happy movie-going!

blobuesky, Jan 24 2007

Instead of jamming it OFF, why not have the blocker turn every phone in range to be turned to VIBRATE mode? That way, people can still get their potential emergency call and the class is not disrupted.

Also, the blocker could be used to block INTERNET access as well. Some people like to take notes on their laptop, but professors don't like it. Take out the worry and focus on teaching

shawnp, Jan 24 2007

What happened to the old fashioned way of reaching someone with a possible emergency like a pregnant wife in labor. Babies came long before cell phones were invented. And as for the job offers, it could wait until after class, lunch, etc. , and believe it or not, Doctors used to go to movies without waiting for cell phone calls too.

galady1106, Mar 19 2007