WhyNot?

Keys order on key board

Category: Questions
Responses: 3 (3 in support, 0 neutral, 0 in opposition)
Number of views: 2360
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Average AverageYour Rating:

Why are the keys of a key board unorderly?

Why can't we put them in their natural order? like A, B, C, D and so on.

Any scientific reason behind this?

I had the same problem and wondered too but never figured out the reason behind this mathematics. It still is a puzzle.

I think, it will make much easier for beginners, who take half an hour to find a letter,feel embarrased, and shun this wonderfull tool.

Naresh Ahuja, Feb 03 2007

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Other ideas in category (Questions):

Fun Questions (3 votes) Average
self powered generator (6 votes) Average
Poles apart (1 votes) Average
Improbable Motion (2 votes) Average
Google chrome (1 votes) Average
Fat Black Holes (1 votes) Average
whynots icon (1 votes) Average
Labs on rent (1 votes) Average
Half-size Cigarettes? (21 votes) Very strong
body heat as energy (1 votes) Average
heating coils (1 votes) Average
How to stop burst pipes? (1 votes) Average
windturbine in forced air syst (2 votes) Average
hydraulics for electricity (1 votes) Average
3D tv (0 votes) Very weak
Carbon nanotubes (1 votes) Average
3.14159265... (1 votes) Average
never the same shape (1 votes) Average
better apps (1 votes) Average
archery techniques (1 votes) Average
use Bluetooth to read RFID tag (2 votes) Average
Stock market (1 votes) Average
Salt water Fuel (1 votes) Average
Take Advantage of Marketers (2 votes) Average
Writing question (1 votes) Average
Public School Fundraising (5 votes) Average
Why buy np-bg1 here (3 votes) Weak
Why can't you tickle yourself? (2 votes) Average
Comments for negative votes (10 votes) Average
Perpetual motion (3 votes) Average
hydrogen from lightning (3 votes) Average
Energy of water (2 votes) Average
Encouraging Generosity (3 votes) Average
Equity sharing for renters (6 votes) Weak
day of 100,000 seconds (1 votes) Average
Aircraft tires (2 votes) Average
Nicotine Inhaler (2 votes) Average
Black hole point of view (3 votes) Weak
nuclear energy (3 votes) Weak
How to convert force to motion (4 votes) Average
ENERGY PRODUCTION (5 votes) Weak
Why don't they feel my pain? (1 votes) Average
Some ideas+ for Traffic (1 votes) Average
Fastest Man-Made Object (1 votes) Average
Space-Orbital Transfer (3 votes) Average
Where are the stars? (4 votes) Average
I can C clearly now..or can I? (1 votes) Average
What happened to StarLite? (2 votes) Average
More Money (2 votes) Average
Curiousity (2 votes) Average
Keys order on key board (3 votes) Average
Using Why Not Ideas (9 votes) Strong
Dreams- A reality (1 votes) Average
Degree of agreement (1 votes) Average
Neutral vote (5 votes) Average
Prevent getting "plowed in"? (1 votes) Average
What's that smell? (3 votes) Average
Difference?? (4 votes) Average
Loose to Gain? (2 votes) Average
What am I missing? (2 votes) Average
Fragile (1 votes) Average
How to Increase Organ Donation (3 votes) Average
Why not use 'how to'? (1 votes) Average
virtual strike public company? (1 votes) Average
Standardize Keypads (2 votes) Average
Problems Instead of Answers (7 votes) Strong
Website for Ideas (1 votes) Average
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

The standard qwirty keyboard was designed to minimize jams on early typewriters. If you want a more efficient keyboard, you can set up your computer to use the Dvorak simplified keyboard. That's actually what I use. For more info, check out this. Dvorak

Dwane Anderson, Feb 03 2007

I just noticed that I misspelled QWERTY above. That's because I typed it on my Dvorak keyboard. I actually forgot how QWERTY was spelled. I haven't been using Dvorak very long and I'm still slow as molasses on it, but then I couldn't type fast before either. It is certainly efficient. I particularly like the fact that the vowels are all in a row under my left fingers.

To answer your original question, an ABCD keyboard would be very fast to learn, but very inefficient to type with. Even less efficient than the QWERTY.

Dwane Anderson, Feb 03 2007

Dwane

I have seen the site.

But I really wonder,

isn't it all a matter of training, practice and getting used to it?

Is there any nature-made mental-pattern or fingure- movement pattern attached to it?

Has any one seriously experimented on it in the recent past? ( Specially on children)

How does it matter if you type a little slower than shunning this machine in the first place? Very many of users write using only one finger.

Why can't we make it much simpler for them, segregating all the keys as per their distinct categories? Like numbers, symbols, system keys etc.( eliminating all the F keys) and making seperate and distinct blocks of such keys.So that when they have to find a key they only look in the relevant block and not get lost in the miss-mass of the presently designed key boards.

Naresh Ahuja, Feb 05 2007

Read the site. Check out the links. I'm not going to rehash all the info available there.

Dwane Anderson, Feb 05 2007

The standard qwerty keyboard has not been put randomly together because of a a cool sounding name. qwerty.. it does sound cool though. The keyboard is put together in such a manner that the letters used the most in regular english are most easily accessable. Studies were performed by "TheM", who, i can not say as I am too tired to research it as of now, but there have been many studies done.

mclf90, Feb 11 2007

Mclf90, did you read my post above? Did you check out the web site? Here's another one The Dvorak Keyboard and You There are many others.

Dwane Anderson, Feb 11 2007

Copyright © Barry Nalebuff & Ian Ayres