WhyNot?

Convertible buildings

Category: Other
Responses: 3 (3 in support, 0 neutral, 0 in opposition)
Number of views: 928
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Average AverageYour Rating:

Why not design schools such that their purpose can evolve with the demographics of the locality they serve? This would entail thinking ahead -- so that 10-20 years from launch, the school could be repurposed as a community centre, and eventually, to a seniors' residence. This means building in redundancy in the short term, but foregoing the pain of wrecking and rebuilding in the medium to long terms. I am not an architect so have no idea if this is practical, but it's worth considering.

dreid, Nov 04 2003

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Ending the war on drugs (245 votes) Very strong
Refrigerator (112 votes) Very strong
Cable TV (92 votes) Very strong
Reverse Ebay: Want to buy XYZ (71 votes) Very strong
Key Number (43 votes) Very strong
Recycling Water (37 votes) Very strong
Jury Duty: Let Us Choose When (33 votes) Very strong
Artsy Tiles (26 votes) Very strong
Ringtones for Landlines (31 votes) Very strong
Ring for Service @ Restaurant (40 votes) Very strong

Other ideas in category (Other):

Finding a parking space (22 votes) Very strong
Flight Data Recorder (5 votes) Strong
TRAVEL ON A DISC 3FT HEIGHT (1 votes) Average
repair ballpoint pens (6 votes) Average
texting while driving (2 votes) Average
Introduce 'talking' or 'quiet' (3 votes) Average
Double sided Velcro tape (3 votes) Average
Bike lanes with raised curb (1 votes) Average
Dinosaur Playground Equipment (4 votes) Average
Taking out the pirates (2 votes) Average
yardsale.com (4 votes) Average
Bicycle tracking / Recovery (3 votes) Average
A weapon ends all weapons (0 votes) Very weak
Reality show idea (2 votes) Average
human condition & money (3 votes) Average
An Idea to get More Ideas (2 votes) Average
Energy: LiD EMP Fusion (3 votes) Average
Bring back Led Zeppelin!!!!! (3 votes) Average
Move Mars to better orbit (9 votes) Weak
Underwater Fighter Pilots (2 votes) Average
Air Pressure Rocket Launcher (1 votes) Average
Tumble suit (3 votes) Average
Magnetic velcro (1 votes) Average
Soda Mix (1 votes) Average
WORLD TAX (2 votes) Average
Convertible buildings (3 votes) Average
more efficient calendar (2 votes) Average
Rechargable TV Remote (8 votes) Average
Lottery at PayTolls (1 votes) Average
Directions (In plain English.) (1 votes) Average
Self-Cooling Bullets (2 votes) Average
creditcards Safety (2 votes) Average
free furnace (2 votes) Average
High tent for outdoor concerts (1 votes) Average
DVR Sharing/Networking (1 votes) Average
dentistry on a plane (3 votes) Average
Glass with thermometer (3 votes) Average
Radio TiVo (11 votes) Strong
FREE SNAIL MAIL (2 votes) Average
Clothing Exchange (2 votes) Average
Cold weather gloves (2 votes) Average
Single wallet ID card (3 votes) Average
Digital Photo Editing Service (2 votes) Average
Twist surprise egg machine (1 votes) Average
mom's cuddle (4 votes) Average
Poinsettia Recycling (2 votes) Average
baby (4 votes) Average
Cigarettes w/ Strikeable Tips (3 votes) Average
Virtual planets (2 votes) Average
Unique Voice Generation (1 votes) Average
Voice clarity (2 votes) Average
Babyface (1 votes) Average
Transatlantic By Pendulum (6 votes) Weak
Life Indicators on batteries (2 votes) Average
authors for hire (3 votes) Average
Use Commuters as a workforce (0 votes) Very weak
Texture Mapping Digital Camera (2 votes) Average
Hanging jigsaw puzzle (1 votes) Average
Hanging jigsaw puzzle (2 votes) Average
Jigsaw Puzzle w/out Cover Pic (2 votes) Average
Mobile Sun Block Booth (4 votes) Average
Useless info on top whynot.net (1 votes) Average
Dispersion Channels (2 votes) Average
Music Search (2 votes) Average
Personalized dolls (2 votes) Average
Erasible printing (5 votes) Strong
Missing Children Channel Plus (2 votes) Average
Pay to View Video Monitor (2 votes) Average
wireless i-pod (15 votes) Strong
Elliminating the carousel (2 votes) Average
Laptop check-in at Wi-Fi cafes (2 votes) Average
Universal ID (passport, DL) (5 votes) Average
Ancient Greece & S. America (7 votes) Weak
Thanksgiving in October (9 votes) Average
stealth shoes (2 votes) Average
Submarine useable space (3 votes) Average
Weapons ideas (6 votes) Average
Seeing through Things (2 votes) Average
Is it OK? (5 votes) Average
centrifugal separation (2 votes) Average
sensor in public toilets (1 votes) Average
exam writer (1 votes) Average
Unify the military services (6 votes) Average
Buy Indivisual Socks (4 votes) Average
All Gum Ball Form (2 votes) Average
Whiteout (1 votes) Average
Actual Movie Times (1 votes) Average
Universal Outlets (1 votes) Average
Pluto's disgrace (3 votes) Average
Roller Coaster Tram (6 votes) Strong
Airliner Building (5 votes) Average
MagLev theme-park flight (6 votes) Average
Split Ownership Mortgage (5 votes) Strong
risk based capital insurance (1 votes) Average
Finger print ID gun. (2 votes) Average
aMaZiNg To0tbRush.. (3 votes) Average
Optic Nerve Signal Recording (2 votes) Average
Double scale thermometer (2 votes) Average
Anti-Airplaine Hijacking (6 votes) Average
abductions (1 votes) Average
The Alarm Lock (1 votes) Average
frequen flyer securityFreepass (5 votes) Weak
Stun Gun on Wild Animals (4 votes) Average
Longtime farming fertilization (1 votes) Average
Dot flasher (1 votes) Average
Lost luggage at the airport (2 votes) Average
More Hand Dryers (4 votes) Average
Book (4 votes) Average
Aquarium Sub Cam (10 votes) Very strong
Daylight savings without tears (7 votes) Weak
Time direction in a multiverse (1 votes) Average
Book title readout (5 votes) Weak
Long Term Care Insurance (1 votes) Average
A Starry Night, for once (6 votes) Strong
Coordinated CC Due Date (1 votes) Average
randomizing start of alphabet (13 votes) Average
Aquarium Subs (8 votes) Strong
Knee Defender (3 votes) Average
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

This is the basis of a paper I wrote for a conference several years back, although not specifically for schools. The basic idea is to finance adaptability rather than sustainability. To do this involves using systemic risk variants as a part of the depreciation of whole life costing.

Unfortunately the costed gains are rarely sufficient to be considered for government buildings, even thought their buildings have long life cycles and low opportunity costs assigned to the value of money. The main reason for this is probably political together with the fact that 'sustainability' is the current buzz-word.

railenvironment, Nov 10 2003

S surplus school in aour area was just that ; as seniors center. Many groups had designs on the school. As of now though, it is slated for demolition. Possible replacements are a two level senior/daycare center and community theater.

classicsat, Nov 11 2003

Good idea. The key here is to build in features that will make it easier to convert the building to another use in the future but don't greatly increase the initial cost. Here, too, we have a lot of old schools that were converted to residences. One of the biggest dilemmas is what to do with the high ceilings. Usually they just put in a false ceiling at residential height and let the extra 3-4 feet go unused. It also means much longer stairways going to second floor than would be the case in an apartment house built from scratch.

RHMorrison, Nov 26 2003

Hospitals are notoriously sick places requiring large sums to be spent to keep infection at bay. Disposable, stackable wards and theatres could be burnt.

wrbell, Nov 28 2003

And I thought you wanted to design buildings with removeable tops.

I think that sounds more fun than this.

hrench, Dec 11 2008