WhyNot?

Electric vehicles can work!

Category: Car
Responses: 13 (8 in support, 0 neutral, 5 in opposition)
Number of views: 508
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Average AverageYour Rating:

I cannot see the problem with the slow charge time/lack of range etc that one always hears about. There is a simple solution which is to have the batteries in standard size packages in a "cassette" form. One can then turn up at a service station and simply pay to swap the empty batteries for new ones with a full charge (such as stage coach horses were changed in the past). No doubt this function could be done mechanically (possibly faster than it takes to refuel with a liquid). The ownership of the batteries could remain with the power provider. The only limit then on the vehicle is the extent of the network of service stations.

dawa, Nov 08 2003

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

This concept is great! (104 votes) Very strong
Better Brake Light (329 votes) Very strong
Refrigerator (84 votes) Very strong
Airport charity (123 votes) Very strong
Ending the war on drugs (183 votes) Very strong
Attachment Notation (117 votes) Very strong
Aerial pictures in flight (160 votes) Very strong
Audio-in Jacks in Cars (141 votes) Very strong
Cable TV (88 votes) Very strong
GPS and Digital Photos (134 votes) Very strong

Other ideas in category (Car):

Friendly Honk Button (6 votes) Strong
energy via wind resistance (4 votes) Average
BATTERY STORAGE AREAS (2 votes) Average
Mini SUV's (1 votes) Average
Electromagnetic propulsion (3 votes) Average
Density Detour System (DDS) (2 votes) Average
"Performance test" GPS (1 votes) Average
SEPARATE ENGINE FOR A/C (2 votes) Average
Car identification (1 votes) Average
Car radio/IPOD/ITUNES sync (2 votes) Average
Carpark e-pass (2 votes) Average
Gyro-car comeback? (2 votes) Average
Write the tyre pressure bigger (8 votes) Strong
Record - live pause car radios (1 votes) Average
Car\'s engine mileage (2 votes) Average
photochromic window tint (4 votes) Average
Wind Generator (8 votes) Weak
STEAM CARS (4 votes) Average
ELECTRIC HYBRID (2 votes) Average
Turbine Electric Vehicle (3 votes) Average
pollution control gadget (3 votes) Weak
Screen Saver on your cell Ph (2 votes) Average
Car safty strip (1 votes) Average
CAR WIND TURBINE (2 votes) Average
Auto Inflate Tires (3 votes) Average
Headlight double switch (2 votes) Average
Parking Lot.com (9 votes) Strong
poor mans turbo (2 votes) Average
Standard plugs? (3 votes) Average
disposable auto-bra (1 votes) Average
Euro format plates in US (1 votes) Average
first time teen driver car (12 votes) Weak
Laser Parking lights (2 votes) Average
Gas cap on BOTH sides of car (4 votes) Weak
no insurance ignition kill (2 votes) Average
SELECTIVE HORN (1 votes) Average
SMALL SINGLE DOOR CAR (10 votes) Average
Jumpstart with drill battery (2 votes) Average
Integrated SatNav Fuel warning (3 votes) Average
Vehicle Emotion Meter (1 votes) Average
Vehicle Signature (1 votes) Average
Reducing rubbernecking (5 votes) Average
iRobot car (4 votes) Average
Dual speed limits by lane (2 votes) Average
Idea for all u boost heads? (5 votes) Average
Folded Car (5 votes) Average
End speeding forever! (1 votes) Average
Better Traffic Management (1 votes) Average
IMPACT BAGS (2 votes) Average
Vehicle to Vehicle Fuel Pump (4 votes) Average
Ding protection (3 votes) Average
traffic monitoring system (2 votes) Average
NYC Parking Exchange (1 votes) Average
Car Seat - Diaper Change Table (1 votes) Average
Diaper changing table in car (2 votes) Average
Backup Signal for Navigation (1 votes) Average
Friendly Horn (3 votes) Average
COMMON MAN'S HYBRID CAR (1 votes) Average
Talking License Plate (1 votes) Average
Car flywheel operatd by clutch (2 votes) Average
Paint Ball Road Lines (2 votes) Average
All Night Car Service (1 votes) Average
Hovercraft with Wheels (1 votes) Average
horn on the back of the car (3 votes) Weak
Undisputed car rental dings (4 votes) Average
High Miles Per Gallon = Useles (6 votes) Average
talk to other drivers (4 votes) Weak
Pre-paid parking card (4 votes) Average
Back up sensor required (3 votes) Weak
Cell Phone Signal Scrambler (8 votes) Weak
RESERVE BATTERY (1 votes) Average
Install a second horn in cars (4 votes) Average
Unfair speeding tickets (5 votes) Average
Heated Ice Scrapers (2 votes) Average
Sun Sensor Auto Glass (3 votes) Average
RFID car info (2 votes) Average
CAR CELL PHONE (2 votes) Average
Air bag for bike safety (4 votes) Weak
BATTERY BAYS (2 votes) Average
Wind turbine generator in cars (2 votes) Average
Flexible Telephone Poles (4 votes) Average
Cars for Kids (2 votes) Average
Run each cylinder independent (1 votes) Average
Problem with hydrogen cars (5 votes) Average
High-Speed Car Transportation (1 votes) Average
eliminate tailgating crs (5 votes) Average
automat glass warmer (1 votes) Average
Self-Turn-Off Turn Signal (4 votes) Average
Eliminate carĀ“s wiper blade (12 votes) Average
Trip meter with cost (3 votes) Average
Car Alarm Notifications (3 votes) Average
CARBON BLACK FILTERS (1 votes) Average
Convertible top[ (7 votes) Average
Airbags on hwy dividers (3 votes) Weak
MAGLEV CARS (2 votes) Average
SOUND MONITOR FOR CARS (3 votes) Average
Electric car recharging (1 votes) Average
Rainwater refill of wiperfluid (4 votes) Average
360 degree camera (3 votes) Average
locale specific speed governor (1 votes) Average
Remote Windows (8 votes) Average
Softer Crashes (2 votes) Average
Electricity speed bump (4 votes) Weak
Accident/Vehicle data network (2 votes) Average
Emission Tires (3 votes) Weak
Internet-enabled Nav (1 votes) Average
Electric vehicles can work! (13 votes) Average
Vacuum Assist Transport System (2 votes) Average
new motor gets 300mpg (4 votes) Average
Recharging electric cars (2 votes) Average
Traveling Service Station (1 votes) Average
Windy thing (3 votes) Weak
Sky Rail - over freeways (2 votes) Average
eliminate tailgating crs (3 votes) Weak
Personal Traffic Alerts (2 votes) Average
Motorhome (1 votes) Average
New way to sell cars (1 votes) Average
preventing car's damage (1 votes) Average
Increasing engine RPM (2 votes) Average
eliminate car advertising (3 votes) Weak
car horn solution (2 votes) Average
Licensing for elderly drivers (12 votes) Very strong
Fuel refill reminder (4 votes) Average
Diesel exhaust (2 votes) Average
GPRS Speed Limit (4 votes) Average
Fuel economy LCD display (4 votes) Average
Half Cars (5 votes) Average
CarTalk (2 votes) Average
My car says hello (13 votes) Weak
Air Bags - - - (3 votes) Average
Tires (2 votes) Average
Manual Car Decals (5 votes) Weak
Floating Cars (3 votes) Average
Car Length Turn Signal (3 votes) Average
Magnetic Mat for Screws (2 votes) Average
Secure Remote Keyless Entry (1 votes) Average
Make better drivers (7 votes) Weak
Speeding Control (6 votes) Weak
Emotive Horn (6 votes) Average
Service Periods (1 votes) Average
U Turn Signal (1 votes) Average
Traffic Light Sensors (3 votes) Average
DMV(Department of Motor Vehicl (3 votes) Average
Auto Gum Dispenser (3 votes) Average
No-hassle rental cars (4 votes) Average
Stopping distance (5 votes) Weak
Intelligent side mirrors (3 votes) Average
Prevent double cranking (4 votes) Average
Heated Fluid (1 votes) Average
Changing car colour (3 votes) Average
Side Defrosters (3 votes) Weak
Stop blowing cold air on me!! (6 votes) Average
Computerized Backseat Driver (1 votes) Average
Wireless auto horn (3 votes) Weak
Noise-cancelling interior (4 votes) Average
Easy side views (2 votes) Average
Vehicle Bluetooth (5 votes) Average
Black-Box in cars (2 votes) Average
Ringing Key (4 votes) Average
fuel-efficient vehicle (3 votes) Average
car parking (4 votes) Average
Cell phones while driving (3 votes) Average
Automatic Window tint (3 votes) Average
Safety Seat (4 votes) Average
Automatic gas pump (4 votes) Average
Wash while at airport (6 votes) Average
universal carpass for pinoys (3 votes) Average
Friendly parking garages (3 votes) Average
easy driving (2 votes) Average
Wheel car (1 votes) Average
Direct Car Communication (3 votes) Average
Car speed recorder (4 votes) Average
wierd vibrations (1 votes) Average
lighter-better cars (2 votes) Average
Stoplight with sensors (1 votes) Average
spare tire alarm (1 votes) Average
passive restraint system (7 votes) Strong
right way to do a hybrid (2 votes) Average
Electromagnetic engine (1 votes) Average
Powdered Biomass Fuel (1 votes) Average
Driving/ Traffic (1 votes) Average
Wi-Fi Car I.D. (1 votes) Average
Non-Disposable Cars (3 votes) Average
Urban Utility Vehicle (4 votes) Average
Little Red Wagons (2 votes) Average
Classic Modern Cars (2 votes) Average
New Car Improvements (4 votes) Weak
DingMonkey Protection (5 votes) Weak
Window Tint (1 votes) Average
Driver Rating System (3 votes) Average
Air bag for bike safety (4 votes) Weak
Color-changing Cars (2 votes) Average
modular model car for dealers (2 votes) Average
Auto Distributor Adva / Retar (1 votes) Average
better night license plates (2 votes) Average
Green Light Timer (3 votes) Average
Parking Lights (2 votes) Average
Energy-saving tips at the pump (4 votes) Average
Automobile refrigerator (3 votes) Weak
Photochronatic windscreen (2 votes) Average
Inter car communication unit (2 votes) Average
No need for more highways (2 votes) Average
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

I've been thinking about something along these lines too. The problem is that what you want to buy is power. So, when you exchanged a battery, you'd need to know how much power had been put into it, and how much power is left in the one you're surrendering. So, you'd need to establish(a) a secure metering system, which is beyond reasonable tampering, and(b) battery technology which would not "leak" power away, and really would deliver upwhatever had been put into it.

Incidentally, with regenerative braking and home-charging (i.e. making the meters run backwards) you'd be able to sell power back to the power companies! I guess you'd have to rent the batteries by the month to give the "power" companies any return, same as you do with welding-gas cylinders.

Jules May, Nov 08 2003

I agree with this idea, and have long thought the same. I am not sure I think the problem of "juice" left in the battery when it is exchanged is too serious. Could fairly easily be addressed by giving you a discount or if not, then I guess users would just take the rough with the smooth.

Wimbledonian, Nov 09 2003

I don't think you're talking about a cassete size battery here. I think the battery would be heavier than anything people can carry without machines. this is not the kind of battery that your jump start, and it would need to supply tons of power. my hybrid battery is huge and it handles less than half the work. so i don't think this is going to work.

aschmidt, Nov 10 2003

do you have any idea how big the batteries are for an electric/hybrid car?!?!?!?!?! probably the primary portion of the weight of the car!

sam3000, Nov 10 2003

Why fiddle about with charging batteries?! Buy a Toyota Prius hybrid - I've had one for over two years now, and it is an ideal car - no fuss, no bother; just get into it and drive!

gaunt, Nov 11 2003

The "cassette" Would be an assembly or three that mounts under the car. Theye would have charge/useage monitoring the charge.

When you exchange the battery in your car, you'd be exchanging it as-is, for a full battery (so if you have some charge on it, you'd be out that cost, unless they can account for the charge left in returned battery, I imagine you'd have an account of some sort).

You would have in the battery, a chip that monitors charge/discharge, in much the same way laptop computer batteries have charge monitor chips.

classicsat, Nov 12 2003

A problem would be the quality of the battery. You might leave behind a wrecked old battery and take away a perfect new one. Who would pay for the difference, and who would monitor it? I don't know how similar systems work (eg gas bottles, containers for articulated lorries) - is it based on trust and the notion that it all averages out eventually?

patrickmurphy, Nov 13 2003

Good idea and practical from my experiences with various power packs in the military. But may I suggest some type of "solid fuel" fuel cell? I remember many years ago an Australian company building a nice little car that had a zinc/oxygen solid type cell. You simply drove into a station, pulled out a 5 pound module with the "spent" zinc and inserted a new one. Refuel time was a few seconds! If more power was needed, you could provide more modules. I believe their problem at the time was perception....no one wanted a small, environmentally friendly car!

DaleW, Dec 21 2003

There are usually 10 to 16 batteries in an electric car so that cassette would weigh more than an engine. The pack would only last a few hours before needing a re-charge. I don't want to 'gas up' a few times a day. Pure electric vehicles just won't be convenient unless they solve the battery problem.

youcanbugme, Jul 16 2004

Hydrogen burning cars! Hydrogen/electric hybrid... You burn hydrogen in a specially made rotary engine that doesn't have many touching parts (Pistons sliding up and down a cylinder wall). The Hydrogen engine turns an electric alternator that routs through a water (H²O) tank. The water tank is separated into two different chambers bridged by a small pipe (So that the electrons can flow through). Using the process of electrolysis you separate the H²O into two separate gasses; you possibly compress them and use the Hydrogen and Oxygen for fuel (Hydrogen and Oxygen give a powerful and clean burn, turning back into water!!). You could also use a percentage of the Oxygen for a closed cabin (when driving in areas with possible toxins). I think this would be the best way to go, seeing as water as a fuel source doesn't seem too bad at all...

A small diagram I did of my innovation. http://www.geocities.com/kensei7776/H2Oengine.JPG

I was stuck on the idea of trying to figure out how to have a power source that was cheap, and on April 19th 2002 (made myself log the date in memory because I thought I was going to make a change!!) I looked the idea up on the internet and it turned out the idea had been originally thought of by the guys who conceived traffic lights back in the 1930's.

Good concept in my opinion. Yes, I know Electrolysis is a sloooooow process, but that just means you Arc in more than one chamber.

Kensei, Jul 16 2004

Not a new concept, it's been researched and was under development some years ago. Logically, one would go to the same place everyone else buys gasoline, except you would go in for a battery pack change. Basically, you would own your car but lease the battery pack, just as I do now with my propane tank exchange (or my welding gas bottles). Propane tank exchanges are a sort of lease that is renewed whenever you exchange the tank (which is why exchanges are more expensive than simply having your own tank filled). My welding tank lease has a term of 3 years, and must be renewed at the end of the lease.

Battery packs would have to be modularized and standardized, of course, and you'll have to figure out how to make money doing this, but it's a good idea. I think personally I'll go with a diesel-electric hybrid minivan or midsize pickup.

Beaugrand, Sep 23 2005

I've been thinking about that too, but it depends on why you would ant to use it my dad pointed out to me that the power has to come from somewhere so if you're doing it to be an environmentalist then your effort is wasted.

Malaki, Dec 02 2005

Batteries for vehicles are very heavy, and often very many. But what you might be able to do is cycle out the liquid electrolyte and put in freshly charged electrolyte. A single connector could be designed to purge and fill the batteries while protecting the user from dripping or spilled acid.

Design cars so the batteries slide in and out of a compartment with the aid of a customized dolly. Changing the battery would be faster than filling a tank of gas.

The government would need to standardize the batteries, charge indicators, etc, and make it illegal to mess with them.

Battery charging stations could be anywhere there was a power source - power lines, windmills, etc. Also, no worries about leaking underground gas tanks at service stations. Even mobile battery changing trucks would be possible, for those stranded.

Had the same idea myself.

Belmont, Oct 24 2007