WhyNot?

Ending cigarette butt litter

Category: Communities
Responses: 8 (5 in support, 0 neutral, 3 in opposition)
Number of views: 1491
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Average AverageYour Rating:

OK - Up here in the N.E. United States, smokers seem to be incapable of disposing of their cigarette butts properly. I see several drivers flicking their butts out their car windows every day as well as regular people just going about their everyday work treating the whole state as 1 giant freakin ashtray. Anyway, here's the idea to curb it. How about a "butt bounty"? Take, for example a pack of 20 cigarettes. Starting from an agreed on date, the cost of a pack of 20 cigarettes say will go up by, say, 2 or 3 dollars (or whatever amount is considered significant) UNLESS the buyer turns in 20 butts in which case, the price is the same as it is now. This might encourage smokers to put their butts back in the them empty box say and turn them in when they buy their next pack instead of decorating the country with their crap. Any takers?

Phel, Oct 10 2008

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Other ideas in category (Communities):

I have an idea (1 votes) Average
Teaching Ethical Reasoning (12 votes) Average
Prisoners teach school kids (9 votes) Weak
Community service/fund-raising (2 votes) Average
New category (1 votes) Average
Mine shaft cities (5 votes) Strong
Daycare (2 votes) Average
Witness Pay (7 votes) Weak
Friendsmind.com - Ask Anything (2 votes) Average
Summer Camp for Adults (4 votes) Average
Drug Free Communities (6 votes) Weak
Online Yard Sales (4 votes) Average
People-friendly Jewelry (3 votes) Average
HUMAN ELECTRO POWER (5 votes) Strong
The Ultimate Plastic House (3 votes) Average
Home Volunteering (2 votes) Average
Blind Picture Finding Service (1 votes) Average
Higher Fines for SUVs (14 votes) Weak
Unadopted Children (4 votes) Average
Ending cigarette butt litter (8 votes) Average
habitat for humanity (3 votes) Average
Magazines for the Blind (2 votes) Average
Public Workshop (7 votes) Strong
No more Icy and freezed roads (3 votes) Average
Social Credit Card (3 votes) Average
Tax Energy - Not Income (5 votes) Weak
Freecycle for the Blind (1 votes) Average
Spend A Penny fundraising idea (1 votes) Weak
Three Great Ideas (2 votes) Average
Community Specific Craigslist (3 votes) Average
Accountability Manager (1 votes) Average
share Drive (2 votes) Average
Currency for the Homeless (8 votes) Average
nonprofit soccer academy india (1 votes) Average
Toys Garage Sale (1 votes) Average
Referral and Network Marketing (1 votes) Average
How to prevent aggressions. (9 votes) Weak
Star Night (8 votes) Strong
Promote Religious Rationality (5 votes) Weak
Obnoxious pedestrians (4 votes) Average
neighborrow.com (2 votes) Average
Neighborhood media offices (4 votes) Weak
Suggestion for climate change (9 votes) Very weak
City bulk transport (4 votes) Average
Public Memorials (2 votes) Average
The 'mission movement' again (2 votes) Average
www.pilgrim.web (3 votes) Average
A New Way to Water Plants (2 votes) Average
Highway markers (3 votes) Average
Wikicity council - democracy (4 votes) Average
Bike Lock Meters (6 votes) Average
Slanted Curbs (6 votes) Weak
Observer sites (4 votes) Average
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

Carrying a pack of stinking (literally) cigarette butts in your pocket would not be popular. Someone once posted the idea of making biodegradable cigarette butts. That would probably go over better.

Dwane Anderson, Oct 11 2008

Hmm...let's see...the choice is make the smokers carry around their own stinking butts or let them throw them all over the place for everyone to enjoy. That's a tough one....

Phel, Oct 11 2008

I think you're missing the point. Make the bounty high enough that every time they throw out a butt, they're literally throwing money out. This is very similar to bottle deposits. If you throw out that beer bottle, you're throwing 10 cents in the garbage.

Even as a smoker, the idea is a little gross, but equally, as someone who works in a public position, I understand the headaches and the mess of cleaning up cigarette butts, so I would support this idea.

In order to make it effective, it would just be a matter of making the 'deposit' high enough. It could also spawn a mini-industry of 'butt-keepers' - little containers specifically designed to hold cigarette butts.

Ennovative, Oct 11 2008

for 3$ extra a pack, i wonder how many people will switch to roll their own filterless cigarettes and then throw the tail end of the cigarette on the ground? ... and then what of people who buy loose tobacco and boxes of tubes - will my 3$ box of tubes now cost 30? i would like to concentrate more on making cigarettes less addictive in the first place

myparadigm, Oct 12 2008

I don't understand why people driving won't put the darn things in their car ashtray.

As it is now, whenever I see someone throw out a butt, or any trash for that matter, I honk and point my finger at them.

Mostly they're embarrassed, but some point back at me with the 'other' finger. I just don't understand how they can see littering as acceptable.

hrench, Oct 13 2008

Amen hrench. I cannot figure it out either. Up in the NE, every road intersection is drowning in cigarette butts as are all the sidewalks outside malls etc (despite trash cans being within reach). I absolutely cringe to think what happens when the rain washes all this crap down the drains. The weird thing is that I haven't seen the same littering when it comes to "normal" stuff like paper cups, bags etc? I very rarely see anyone tossing those items on the ground from a car or otherwise. This phenomenon seems to be restricted to cigarette butts. I guess these moronic litterers think cigarette butts are too small to matter.

Phel, Oct 14 2008

I know it to be a FACT that 95% of all trash in the US are comprised up of little write rappers!o)

krispykreemd, Oct 17 2008

at risk of everyone hating me :P i can probably answer your questions as i smoke, and often litter my butts...
- why not use car ashtray? because then the car would stink. no it doesnt stink already because I only smoke with the window open and put the cigarette outside at lights.
same goes for keeping the butts on me then i would stink (a lot more)
-garbage cans? yes, when i have that option i do put it in the garbage. If not, it would be because it can be a fire hazard, however, i have begun rolling the cherry off to get around this.
-and I am very stringent about not littering, even bothering others if they do, but butts are natural fibers - they will eventually compost. I feel about as guilty as if i were to throw away a banana peel
people would probably make more of an effort if they knew how much it bothered others




myparadigm, Oct 22 2008

There must be a reasonable way of recycling the butts of smokes...the first person to figure it out is going to make a lot of money!

Bigdog_mike, Oct 24 2008