WhyNot?

lie detectors

Category: Legal
Responses: 4 (1 in support, 0 neutral, 3 in opposition)
Number of views: 966
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Weak WeakYour Rating:

million dollar trials, wrongful imprisonment, and the guilty go free. the solution is so so simple, I dont know why it hasnt been done yet. I've read that computerized polygraphs are very accurate, factor in some redundancy and I wouldnt doubt they'd be foolproof. most trials would last maybe 30-60 minutes, probably cost less than 1000$, and accuracy of conviction skyrocket.

myparadigm, Oct 22 2008

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Ending the war on drugs (269 votes) Very strong
Ziploc chip bags (111 votes) Very strong
WhyNot Wiki (18 votes) Very strong
Incarceration (19 votes) Very strong
Washer n' Dryer in one (16 votes) Very strong
Pay Per channel TV (14 votes) Very strong
Half-size Cigarettes? (21 votes) Very strong
Government buyout (10 votes) Strong
End Age Discrimination (5 votes) Strong
Censor Blocking (7 votes) Strong

Other ideas in category (Legal):

Cities:Warn Visitors Of Dangers (1 votes) Average
Dueling License (6 votes) Average
DNA database 4 paternity hunt (1 votes) Average
Employers: check web or B sued (1 votes) Average
Outlaw The Tattooing of Drunks (1 votes) Average
Incarceration (19 votes) Very strong
Video Jury Duty (2 votes) Average
Easier Internet Prosecution (2 votes) Average
Jury Duty: Let Us Choose When (37 votes) Very strong
No More Copyrights (5 votes) Weak
Revenue from Fines (1 votes) Average
Video Testimony&Appearance (1 votes) Average
organ donation (3 votes) Average
Make it Illegal to Own Land (4 votes) Weak
Pay For DNA And Fingerprints (1 votes) Average
Remove illegal jail tattoos (1 votes) Average
New form of Government (2 votes) Average
Immigration Insurance (8 votes) Average
Parental licencing (27 votes) Weak
Death Penalty Waiver (1 votes) Average
Drug Incinerator (2 votes) Average
laws agenced art (1 votes) Average
Find the ship,kill the pirates (5 votes) Average
Gladiators (3 votes) Weak
Alcohol Buyers' Fingerprints (4 votes) Weak
brain firewall? (7 votes) Weak
Zoning victimless crimes (9 votes) Average
Green Card Lottery (7 votes) Weak
Car Race-Car Chase-Closed Case (2 votes) Average
Changing prisons (3 votes) Average
Gun Control (29 votes) Very weak
Make Michigan Free Drug State (4 votes) Average
Fair trial. (9 votes) Weak
lie detectors (4 votes) Weak
End Age Discrimination (5 votes) Strong
Censor Blocking (7 votes) Strong
A different approach to crime. (6 votes) Average
Lawsuit Brokerage (6 votes) Average
Death penalty alternative (14 votes) Weak
Oil spills (1 votes) Average
Tax punitive damages (7 votes) Average
Fat Tax (43 votes) Very weak
quick fix (3 votes) Weak
frivolous v. legit lawsuits (6 votes) Average
Divorce Insurance (9 votes) Strong
Medical Court (3 votes) Average
Public Defender in Civil Suits (2 votes) Average
Class Actions and Attorney Fee (0 votes) Very weak
Approve Judges in Pairs (3 votes) Weak
Legal Status Reports On-line (3 votes) Average
Illegally acquired evidence (4 votes) Average
Lawyers not needed here (7 votes) Strong
Mandatory Credit Auction (2 votes) Average
Affirmative Action For Ugly Pe (9 votes) Very weak
Testing notes for drugs (5 votes) Weak
Class Action Remedy (2 votes) Average
Car Repair Ripoff (2 votes) Average
Legal documents on a website (1 votes) Average
Bankruptcy Reconcilliation (2 votes) Average
government settlement database (4 votes) Average
Bribing your client to settle (2 votes) Average
voting clubs (4 votes) Weak
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

Lie detectors have been proven inaccurate time after time. Trust in them is totally misplaced.

sand, Oct 22 2008

Lie detectors don't rely on the machine, they rely on the person operating the machine thus leaving room for error. They are not accurate.

MrCoder, Oct 26 2008

such narrow mindedness. i couldnt find the article on computerized polygraphs, i read it a long time ago. but here is something else i found after 5 minutes on google.

"In all cases, the polygraph and fMRI accurately distinguished truthful responses from deceptive ones."http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2004/11/041130235442.htm

myparadigm, Nov 01 2008

Copyright © Barry Nalebuff & Ian Ayres