WhyNot?

Dating site that doesn't suck

Category: Computer
Responses: 3 (3 in support, 0 neutral, 0 in opposition)
Number of views: 827
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Average AverageYour Rating:

There is very little innovation in online dating. Most dating sites just allow you to post a picture and a profile, and that's about it. A problem with this is that a self-written profiles isn't a very accurate representation of one's self. Also, people often don't KNOW what they want in dating, so keyword searchs are ineffective.

How about a dating site that uses collaborative filtering for finding people you would naturally get along with? Very similar to Amazon's "if you like this book, you'll also probably like this book". But in this case it would be, "if you are best friends with this person, you are likely to be best friends with this person". You can use myspace and facebook as your dataset and perhaps mish-mash them with other datasets that are also good predictors (for instance credit scores, books you like to read, hotornot scores of types of people you tend to find attractive, etc).

Ian Ayres' excellent SuperCrunchers book discusses the statistical process in a bit more detail. But I always thought that if this works for books, why can't it work for online dating?

Anyone interested in programming something like this with me?

Steve Quezadas, Dec 04 2008

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Other ideas in category (Computer):

PASSWORD GADGET (2 votes) Average
English Programming Language (3 votes) Average
A keyboard for your lap (2 votes) Average
Ultimate Translator (9 votes) Strong
Laptop (3 votes) Average
Wireless mouse switch (2 votes) Average
A Better Music Solution (3 votes) Average
Network Global Drives (1 votes) Average
PCI DSL Modem (1 votes) Average
BRIEFCASE LAPTOP (2 votes) Average
Noisefree Computing (1 votes) Average
Built in DSL/Cable Modem (2 votes) Average
Spam vs. Scam (1 votes) Average
PCI LAN CARD LEDs' (1 votes) Average
No More Floppy Drive Headers (3 votes) Average
The Undercover Web (1 votes) Average
Programmable Desktop Wallpaper (2 votes) Average
Software Folding Contest (1 votes) Average
Free bulk email/spamming svc (5 votes) Weak
Speeding up oft-visited sites (2 votes) Average
Handwriting for touch screens (3 votes) Average
Braille eReader (1 votes) Average
twitter vision (2 votes) Average
Highlight Text in 2-column PDF (2 votes) Average
A ONLINE LINUX UNIVERSITY (1 votes) Average
Keyboard protector (6 votes) Average
computerless concept (4 votes) Weak
wireless internet in cars (8 votes) Average
Name dictionary (9 votes) Strong
LAPTOP MONITOR (2 votes) Average
SEARCH ENGINE that PAYS YOU (3 votes) Weak
WiMantic (1 votes) Average
PCO cum Email sender (1 votes) Average
Mouse with a cable connector (4 votes) Average
Facebook + Craigslist (37 votes) Very strong
Bent Pen drives (2 votes) Average
Classified Super Computers (2 votes) Average
FOLDABLE LCD DISPLAYS (2 votes) Average
Dating site that doesn't suck (3 votes) Average
handheld Mouse ala tv remote (2 votes) Average
lighted computer keys (1 votes) Average
PC with a rotating stand (2 votes) Average
MEMO PEN (1 votes) Average
Web 2.0 Flashcard Website (5 votes) Strong
Map Directions with Landmarks (5 votes) Strong
BUBBLE SONG STICK (3 votes) Weak
USB RAM (3 votes) Average
3 Screen Laptop (4 votes) Average
Pornography Solution Finally (1 votes) Average
Indexed Thesaurus (2 votes) Average
Hibernate button (2 votes) Average
Protecting Sensitive Info (2 votes) Average
Single Financial Statement (2 votes) Average
Burglar Deterrent Software (3 votes) Average
Light Emming Stickers (1 votes) Average
1.5 inch mini cds (1 votes) Average
NEW LAN CONNECTOR (2 votes) Average
Scan and Search (1 votes) Average
Printing white (1 votes) Average
UNIVERSAL LAPTOP HANDLE (3 votes) Average
Flag-rare-words feature needed (1 votes) Average
Genate energy from the heat (3 votes) Average
How about a MacBook Light? (1 votes) Average
An Idea for MacBook Light (1 votes) Average
Portable Cable Data Modem (1 votes) Average
Internet pornography solution2 (6 votes) Average
Smart ID Cards (3 votes) Average
FACE ID CARD (3 votes) Weak
www.complaint-here.com (2 votes) Average
LCD PROJECTOR CUM LAPTOP (5 votes) Strong
Connectivity on Airplanes (4 votes) Average
DVD WRITER/LABEL PRINTER (1 votes) Average
LAPTOP HANDLE (2 votes) Average
dvd rom changer for laptop (2 votes) Average
ROUND/OVAL SHAPED LAPTOPS (3 votes) Average
USB LAMP (1 votes) Average
USB FAN (2 votes) Average
Keyboard protection (2 votes) Average
New Type of Laptop (2 votes) Average
PEN PC (1 votes) Average
MP3 Player Tree (2 votes) Average
PEN DVD (1 votes) Average
PEN SCANNER (1 votes) Average
MEMBRANE MOUSE (1 votes) Average
Obit (3 votes) Average
Street light bulbs with wifi (5 votes) Average
RAM DISK (4 votes) Average
Ultra hip iTunes (1 votes) Average
Email and Spam (4 votes) Average
Web based OS development (1 votes) Average
Password Manager (1 votes) Average
Metadata for TV (1 votes) Average
Context Frame (1 votes) Average
Commerce Internet (2 votes) Average
User Friendly ideas (3 votes) Average
IE URL QUEUE (3 votes) Average
Hear your TV channel remotely (3 votes) Average
Central Software System (2 votes) Average
An OS of the 3rd Dimension (4 votes) Average
Download from BlackBerry (1 votes) Average
Projectable LCD monitor (1 votes) Weak
Print from Monitor (1 votes) Average
Stop spam forever (4 votes) Average
MIA MEMORY IN AIR (1 votes) Weak
Cooling plates as tower walls (1 votes) Average
MP3 for swimming (15 votes) Very strong
Facebook + Email (2 votes) Average
Wish List (4 votes) Average
Auto Vote (4 votes) Average
GPS ETA Alarm (3 votes) Average
Printer Gauge (2 votes) Average
Watching video tapes (2 votes) Average
Automated Want Ads (3 votes) Average
HOT Labtop to Cool labtop (4 votes) Average
Synchronize email and files (3 votes) Average
Anti-SPAM Method (5 votes) Weak
Storage challenge (3 votes) Average
SMS ur computer (4 votes) Average
Testing testing (2 votes) Weak
Available apps (3 votes) Average
Ebay (2 votes) Average
VDU safe viewing distance (3 votes) Average
Google Toolbar (1 votes) Average
Google reader beta (1 votes) Average
Ebay natural query (3 votes) Average
Replacing Google Search Result (2 votes) Average
Projecting the screen on air (1 votes) Average
Reading and writing from air (1 votes) Average
Easier Google (2 votes) Average
Data storage challenge (1 votes) Average
GUI design for multiple applic (1 votes) Average
Representing multiple items (1 votes) Average
Search results (1 votes) Average
Program Run Sandbox (2 votes) Average
All Shows on iTunes (2 votes) Average
Net Frame (2 votes) Average
Railroad Communications (4 votes) Average
CPU credit card slots (3 votes) Average
Automatic machine search (1 votes) Average
changing wallpaper (1 votes) Average
SENIOR PEOPLE (HRD,SFT & NET) (1 votes) Average
Decentralized number allocat'n (2 votes) Average
memolinker (1 votes) Average
One Big Computer (distributed) (4 votes) Average
Professional Product Pickers (1 votes) Average
Global (1 votes) Average
NO eBay listing fees (3 votes) Average
telemarketing pronunciation pr (2 votes) Average
Teaching -- Building Web Page (4 votes) Average
open source drivers (5 votes) Strong
A coffee next to your PC? (2 votes) Average
Take note of older users (9 votes) Average
Recognize Voice (2 votes) Average
Web printing (3 votes) Average
Peek around windows (4 votes) Average
P2P as the artists friend (4 votes) Average
Expensive printer cartridges (2 votes) Average
Loafer's Friend (3 votes) Average
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

so, you want a holistic matching system from different sources. Why not work it into a social media idea where you match based on user profiles and interests from facebook, friendfeed etc. there's one site that i stumbled upon that claims it will do something similar:

http://sneak.playwithmatches.com/public/home.aspx#

gchakrab, Dec 07 2008

One person can rarely acquire a large number of reviews, and most reviews will be given by someone leaving the relationship. Ouch. Plus, Mr. Perfect for one lady is usually Mr. Wrong for 99 other ladies. I agree there is a lot of room for improvement... but I am not sure how to aggregate accurate & useful data.

wizard1961, Dec 14 2008

Perhaps if it was set up kind of like a speed dating thing... where you gave your first impressions and that was the basis for the ratings? Where everyone knew ahead of time that there was no commitment and gave their reviews anonymously to the site. I LOATHE online dating and will be tracking this so hopefully we can fix the system. I think you're on the right track to have it user-driven though... E-harm and Match are rip offs!

WestIndianAngel, Jan 14 2009