WhyNot?

Cash card

Category: Financial
Responses: 3 (1 in support, 1 neutral, 1 in opposition)
Number of views: 232
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Average AverageYour Rating:

Use Metro cards in New York and D.C as cash cards?

ppalas, Nov 19 2003

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Audio-in Jacks in Cars (136 votes) Very strong
Airport charity (120 votes) Very strong
Ending the war on drugs (178 votes) Very strong
Cable TV (87 votes) Very strong
Remove TV Sports Commentary (14 votes) Very strong
Search?? (6 votes) Strong
Instant Message Feature (10 votes) Strong
donate my rebate (4 votes) Average
voicemail call screening (2 votes) Average
Auction my work on ebay (2 votes) Average

Other ideas in category (Financial):

Comments from other members:

Add your comment

That's what a Debit card is for.(In Canada, the card you use for ATM transactionscan be used for store purchases, I understand in the USA you must get a card specifically for such transactions.)

Then there is Mondex, which uses an electronic smartcard to store monetary values on the card. With that, you can have person to person transfers, in addition to bank-person and retailer-person.

classicsat, Nov 20 2003

Debit cards are not hard to use for small amounts and some banks charge for their use. I do not know what a Mondex card is but it sounds like a cash card. The advantage if using a metro card is that there is already cashiers and machines that except cash charge and debit cards all over the city

Thanks for the comment

ppalas, Nov 20 2003

Two problems I have with cards. One is limited use. In the metrocard case, you put money in it but (I think) can not easily get it back out. The same with gift cards. Someone buys you one that's only good at shoes-a-rama and the closest store is 100 miles away and the card expires and the store steals your gift. Phone cards also expire. The other problem is privacy. Cards when used are stored in a database of who you are, what you bought, and where you bought it. None of their business!

Also, almost all stripe cards use the same format. Metrocard is an exception... it can not be read by bank machines.

mr2560, Nov 20 2003

A Mondex card is a crad thah holde the cash value in a chip embedded in it, accessable by contacts on it, much like a phone card.

classicsat, Nov 24 2003

Cards are totally redundant. Cell/mobile phones are the way to go. Just flash your phone past the reader/ATM/cash point, etc. Use your PIN. Monies are immediately withdrawn from your bank a/c and are credited to the stores involved in the transactions. If you lose your phone, it's no worse than losing your wallet, card, or cash.

polohay, May 05 2008