WhyNot?

Medic over Nurse

Category: Medicine
Responses: 7 (3 in support, 0 neutral, 4 in opposition)
Number of views: 888
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Weak WeakYour Rating:

The term "nurse" is explicitly a female term and limits the nursing profession. Men who take up nursing are looking on suspiciously and the profession is still primarily populated by women. This keeps wages low and also reduces the level of respect accorded the profession by society.

The idea is to change the name and use the term "medic" instead of "nurse". This is sexually generic and conveys a better picture of what these people do.

Hugh R Heinsohn

hughrheinsohn, Nov 19 2003

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Better Brake Light (441 votes) Very strong
GPS and Digital Photos (172 votes) Very strong
Audio-in Jacks in Cars (177 votes) Very strong
Elevator DeSelect (160 votes) Very strong
Attachment Notation (137 votes) Very strong
Recycling Water (37 votes) Very strong
Bathroom doors open out (26 votes) Very strong
Pay effective teachers more (21 votes) Very strong
Drivers Ed (24 votes) Very strong
*Night Museums (13 votes) Very strong

Other ideas in category (Medicine):

Comments from other members:

Add your comment

You could call them "medics", "medical specialists", "care givers", what have you, but until enough men join the ranks of this occupation, good old human cognition will conjure up the image of a woman, not a man, every time - and this would go for male nurses as well! We are both blessed and cursed that our brain does not have to start from scratch with every piece of information that comes to us and can build - for better or worse - upon past experience.

Vince, Nov 26 2003

The term "NURSE" refers to one, of ANY gender, who provides care to those in need of medical attention. I work with many men who are wonderful caregivers and who are proud to call themselves nurses.

Medic, however, generally refers to anyone who has received a bare minimum of training. The two should never be confused.

Perhaps, instead of changing the term, we should focus more on changing the narrow-minded among us.

Anyone who bears the title R.N. worked awfully hard to obtain the right to call themselves a nurse. I haven't found anyone who wants to be called anything else.

Joanie, Nov 28 2003

I'm a paramedic who would never want to be catagorized with a gender confused male nurse. R.N.'s generally need permission to wipe there own asses; whereas paramedic's have an extensive scope of practice. I do not know of a paramedic who has a bare minimum of training. I have responded to many nursing facillities where R.N. incompetence has proven fatal. A paramedic should be viewed as a physician's right hand in the field. A R.N.'s right hand can often be found wrist deep in fecal matter while changing a patients undergarments. I haven't found a paramendic who desires any other title. If you want the title "Medic," earn it!

Hue Marx, Sep 15 2006

Doctors. Female or male, I call them doctors. I trust them with my life. I appreciate the care and attention that a nurse can provide. Man or woman. I would also accept a medic's help, though I often imagine needing them in situations I'd rather not be in, like bleeding to death, or crisply fried.

The health care system has greater priorities it should address than gender association issues. That way of thinking is becoming ancient. I'm more concerned about the major hospital that closed in my city because it wasn't making enough *profit*. Does money take that much precedence over human life? Also, why isn't my federal government looking after my well-being, despite its "superpower" status? We can blow terr'ists to high Hell and back with billion dollar bombs, but the homeless man on my corner is out of luck if his health takes a dive. Who will help him? Medics? Nurses?

nayhem, Sep 22 2006