WhyNot?

Transatlantic By Pendulum

Category: Other
Responses: 6 (2 in support, 0 neutral, 4 in opposition)
Number of views: 1213
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Weak WeakYour Rating:

When the new carbon-filament super-strong cables are perfected, a pendulum hanging from orbit could be made. Why not use it for transatlantic or trans-Lake Michigan travel, for example? How fast would it go? I'm sure that could be computed. Either a geostationary orbit could be used or the orbit could be constantly adjusted by rocket-firings. It might be possible to bring back the luxury passengers enjoyed when travelling by airship or Clipper. Passengers would have to quickly board and disembark en masse in a container before the pendulum starts swinging the other way. Planes should avoid the pendulum.

Mulder, Dec 10 2003

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Other ideas in category (Other):

parachutes in airplane (1 votes) Average
vending machine improvement (3 votes) Average
electricity (1 votes) Average
Electricity from sound? (3 votes) Average
Table Saw Video Camera (1 votes) Average
Microwave torch (2 votes) Average
Traffic light vibrator (1 votes) Average
Why Not new ideas RSS feed (2 votes) Average
aytonomus energy boat (2 votes) Average
Substitute for land mines (2 votes) Average
repair ballpoint pens (6 votes) Average
Flight Data Recorder (8 votes) Strong
texting while driving (2 votes) Average
Finding a parking space (24 votes) Very strong
TRAVEL ON A DISC 3FT HEIGHT (1 votes) Average
Introduce 'talking' or 'quiet' (3 votes) Average
Double sided Velcro tape (3 votes) Average
Bike lanes with raised curb (1 votes) Average
Dinosaur Playground Equipment (4 votes) Average
Taking out the pirates (2 votes) Average
yardsale.com (4 votes) Average
Bicycle tracking / Recovery (4 votes) Average
A weapon ends all weapons (0 votes) Very weak
Reality show idea (2 votes) Average
human condition & money (4 votes) Average
An Idea to get More Ideas (3 votes) Average
Energy: LiD EMP Fusion (3 votes) Average
Bring back Led Zeppelin!!!!! (4 votes) Average
Move Mars to better orbit (10 votes) Very weak
Underwater Fighter Pilots (3 votes) Average
Air Pressure Rocket Launcher (1 votes) Average
Tumble suit (3 votes) Average
Magnetic velcro (1 votes) Average
Soda Mix (1 votes) Average
WORLD TAX (2 votes) Average
Convertible buildings (3 votes) Average
more efficient calendar (2 votes) Average
Rechargable TV Remote (8 votes) Average
Lottery at PayTolls (1 votes) Average
Directions (In plain English.) (1 votes) Average
Self-Cooling Bullets (2 votes) Average
creditcards Safety (2 votes) Average
free furnace (2 votes) Average
High tent for outdoor concerts (1 votes) Average
DVR Sharing/Networking (1 votes) Average
dentistry on a plane (3 votes) Average
Glass with thermometer (3 votes) Average
Radio TiVo (11 votes) Strong
FREE SNAIL MAIL (2 votes) Average
Clothing Exchange (2 votes) Average
Cold weather gloves (2 votes) Average
Single wallet ID card (3 votes) Average
Digital Photo Editing Service (2 votes) Average
Twist surprise egg machine (1 votes) Average
mom's cuddle (4 votes) Average
Poinsettia Recycling (2 votes) Average
baby (4 votes) Average
Cigarettes w/ Strikeable Tips (3 votes) Average
Virtual planets (2 votes) Average
Unique Voice Generation (1 votes) Average
Voice clarity (2 votes) Average
Babyface (1 votes) Average
Transatlantic By Pendulum (6 votes) Weak
Life Indicators on batteries (2 votes) Average
authors for hire (3 votes) Average
Use Commuters as a workforce (0 votes) Very weak
Texture Mapping Digital Camera (2 votes) Average
Hanging jigsaw puzzle (1 votes) Average
Hanging jigsaw puzzle (2 votes) Average
Jigsaw Puzzle w/out Cover Pic (2 votes) Average
Mobile Sun Block Booth (4 votes) Average
Useless info on top whynot.net (1 votes) Average
Dispersion Channels (2 votes) Average
Music Search (2 votes) Average
Personalized dolls (2 votes) Average
Erasible printing (5 votes) Strong
Missing Children Channel Plus (2 votes) Average
Pay to View Video Monitor (2 votes) Average
wireless i-pod (15 votes) Strong
Elliminating the carousel (2 votes) Average
Laptop check-in at Wi-Fi cafes (2 votes) Average
Universal ID (passport, DL) (5 votes) Average
Ancient Greece & S. America (7 votes) Weak
Thanksgiving in October (9 votes) Average
stealth shoes (2 votes) Average
Submarine useable space (3 votes) Average
Weapons ideas (6 votes) Average
Seeing through Things (2 votes) Average
Is it OK? (6 votes) Average
centrifugal separation (2 votes) Average
sensor in public toilets (1 votes) Average
exam writer (1 votes) Average
Unify the military services (6 votes) Average
Buy Indivisual Socks (4 votes) Average
All Gum Ball Form (2 votes) Average
Whiteout (1 votes) Average
Actual Movie Times (1 votes) Average
Universal Outlets (1 votes) Average
Pluto's disgrace (3 votes) Average
Roller Coaster Tram (6 votes) Strong
Airliner Building (5 votes) Average
MagLev theme-park flight (6 votes) Average
Split Ownership Mortgage (5 votes) Strong
risk based capital insurance (1 votes) Average
Finger print ID gun. (2 votes) Average
aMaZiNg To0tbRush.. (3 votes) Average
Optic Nerve Signal Recording (2 votes) Average
Double scale thermometer (2 votes) Average
Anti-Airplaine Hijacking (6 votes) Average
abductions (1 votes) Average
The Alarm Lock (1 votes) Average
frequen flyer securityFreepass (5 votes) Weak
Stun Gun on Wild Animals (4 votes) Average
Longtime farming fertilization (1 votes) Average
Dot flasher (1 votes) Average
Lost luggage at the airport (2 votes) Average
More Hand Dryers (4 votes) Average
Book (4 votes) Average
Aquarium Sub Cam (10 votes) Very strong
Daylight savings without tears (7 votes) Weak
Time direction in a multiverse (1 votes) Average
Book title readout (5 votes) Weak
Long Term Care Insurance (1 votes) Average
A Starry Night, for once (6 votes) Strong
Coordinated CC Due Date (1 votes) Average
randomizing start of alphabet (14 votes) Average
Aquarium Subs (8 votes) Strong
Knee Defender (3 votes) Average
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

Not as far as you'd think from what real rocket scientists think is possible. Space Elevator

prion9, Dec 10 2003

I think there is a basic misconception of the forces involved. The orbit point is not a static fixed point that could support the swing of a massive element underneath. It would be a problem merely to keep the space elevator stable. A swinging weight beneath would destabilize the whole system and it most likely would fall, or at minimum, disintegrate in a spectacular manner.

sand, Dec 11 2003

Even if you can build the contruption, the pendalum swings down (into the sea and earth) before it comes up. I don't get it. You could not build one to go between to points which are one mile apart and you need a trench. Am I missing something?

shmuelur, Dec 24 2003

The trench concept has been explored froma different point of view. If a straight tube could be built between two distant points on the surface of the Earth and the tube evacuated to prevent air resistancefrom causing drag on a vehicle, an unpowered vehicle on wheels would roll downhill for half the journey and acquire enough velocity to roll uphill on the other half of the journey to a dead stop at the end. And no matter how long the tube, all journeys (even through the center of the Earth) would take the same time. Unfortunately,our primitive engineering capabilities are not up to constructing this simple economic system.

sand, Jan 28 2004

The idea and related schemes have been around for over a century. The simplest is a cable stretching up to a ballast weight higher than geosynchronous orbit, with the lower end firmly anchored to the Earth's crust; since the ballast is travelling faster than orbital speed, it exerts a continuous pull on the retaining cable. Presumably, a small Near Earth asteroid is captured and used as the ballast. In the event of cable structure failure, the ballast is flung off into space by inertia.

In practice, a capsule would ascend the cable to the geosynchronous orbit altitude, roughly 22,000 miles; at that point it would release and become an independant spacecraft.

The pendulum idea does away with an anchor; the ballast is stationed at the geosynchronous orbit, with several cables attached; as the assembly spins, the cables dip into the atmosphere in succession, pulling up capsules or delivering them to the surface.

As the ballast/cable assembly spins, the 22,000 mile long cables sweep to an altitude of 44,000 miles before descending.

All we need for this is several hundred thousand miles of Larry Niven's "Sinclair molecular chain," a few "antigravity sleds," and a conveniently sized Near-Earth asteroid (nickel-iron preferred).

See Skyhook, Lofstrom Loop, Space Fountain, Space Elevator.

Beaugrand, Nov 14 2007