WhyNot?

No Carry-On Flights

Category: Airline Industry
Responses: 7 (5 in support, 0 neutral, 2 in opposition)
Number of views: 1530
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Average AverageYour Rating:

Why not have some airline flights designated as "no carry-on?" This would help with security issues and greatly speed departure and arrival. Many travelers would gladly forgo carry-on baggage for such advantages.

This idea was originally posted by SETH5447 on the forbes.com Why Not? forum.

lokani24, Jan 06 2004

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Aerial pictures in flight (226 votes) Very strong
Elevator DeSelect (167 votes) Very strong
Refrigerator (121 votes) Very strong
Audio-in Jacks in Cars (186 votes) Very strong
Receiving Pre-Delivery emails (84 votes) Very strong
Ending the war on drugs (260 votes) Very strong
Cable TV (94 votes) Very strong
Attachment Notation (139 votes) Very strong
Ziploc chip bags (107 votes) Very strong
Good Samaritan Switch (60 votes) Very strong

Other ideas in category (Airline Industry):

Airplane tires (13 votes) Strong
Aerial pictures in flight (226 votes) Very strong
Bumpee discount option (2 votes) Average
Carry on all your suitcases (17 votes) Very weak
rental video games and console (4 votes) Average
Finding airline black boxes (2 votes) Average
More Leg Room on the Plane (2 votes) Average
Disable Reclining Airline Seat (22 votes) Average
Party Blimp (6 votes) Average
NTN (Buzztime) Trivia InFlight (2 votes) Average
Luggage carts not carousel (2 votes) Average
Swivel seats in Coach (11 votes) Average
Publish Check-in Waiting Times (5 votes) Strong
Google Maps for plane windows (2 votes) Average
Seating Sections on Airplanes (2 votes) Average
Suitcase Savior (1 votes) Average
Airliner Paracute (5 votes) Weak
KIDS (3 votes) Weak
SENIORS (3 votes) Weak
Overweight planes (19 votes) Very strong
Airline Pre-Boarding (4 votes) Weak
Body Mass Index ticket price (23 votes) Average
Solve plane crashes quickly (10 votes) Average
sleeper seats -- intl. coach (11 votes) Strong
Luggage priority (7 votes) Strong
better plane entry order (4 votes) Average
Sell leg room for money (5 votes) Average
Use two doors to load plane (2 votes) Average
pocket knife checkin (7 votes) Strong
Better way to collect baggage (4 votes) Average
rental laptops in flight (4 votes) Average
Air GPS (3 votes) Average
Cup holders in airline seats (9 votes) Strong
Frequent Flyer miles for time (4 votes) Average
No Carry-On Flights (7 votes) Average
Seating (7 votes) Weak
Frequent Flyer Hours (4 votes) Average
Transparent Overhead Bin Lid (6 votes) Average
Quicker Airline Boarding (9 votes) Average
Passenger Screening Attendants (1 votes) Average
Fly without luggage (13 votes) Weak
Swapping flight times (3 votes) Weak
Fuel tank bladders for airline (3 votes) Weak
Airline Tour in Flight (7 votes) Strong
Deli Line for Boarding (3 votes) Weak
Airline Security (2 votes) Average
FreqFlier Standby (1 votes) Average
Comments from other members:

Add your comment

I agree with that 100%.

mcblahblah, Apr 04 2006

Because it is not what passengers want, is more trouble for the airline and would take more time.

Cut-price airlines (in Europe at least) are increasing hand-luggage allowances and charging for checked-in luggage.
If you have hand-luggage only you can often check-in later, and don't have to wait for your luggage to come off the plane.

Sorry, this one won't work.

ChrisF, Jun 01 2006

I agree with ChrisF, too many people use the carry-on feature now. And with the present system flights still take-off and land on-time.

For security reasons only, I would like to see no carry-ons allowed and people are x-rayed using the low-power versions now available. That way it will catch even those ceramic knives terrorists have been using.

The present reduced hand luggage restrictions are causing chaos. The size limit of 55x40x20cm means you can no longer take on a backpack, only a slim bag. Many people (me included) have been used to day trips, or one night trips, using just hand baggage. I can no longer do this. This means I have to arrive 2 hours before the flight (instead of 30-45 Minutes for hand luggage only), and wait 30 Mins.+ for my luggage to come off the conveyor. a 1½ Hr. flight suddenly becomes 3½ Hrs.

Another problem is drinks. The one thing I absolutely must have as hand luggage is a drink. For years the airlines have been advising you that for medical reasons you should drink lots of fluids. Suddenly they are banning liquids.

There is too much paranoia here. The IRA didn't succeed in shutting down transport in 30 years, and they had more bombs and more people. These so-called security experts are just doing what the terrorists cannot - causing chaos.

ChrisF, Oct 22 2006

And of course if I really wanted to take over a plane, I can still buy the perfect weapon after the security check, a bottle of duty-free whisky. A smashed glass bottle is at least as good a weapon at close quarters as a knife. But they won't stop selling that, it would cut into the airport's profits. The current delays add to airport profits, the longer the passengers are stuck in the departure lounge, the more they buy.

ChrisF, Oct 23 2006