WhyNot?

*Vote for a committee

Category: Government
Responses: 2 (1 in support, 0 neutral, 1 in opposition)
Number of views: 291
Tracking: Track this idea
Community Rating:Average AverageYour Rating:

When our government was first formed over two hundred years ago, it was clear the people would need representatives who they must trust to make decisions of law and policy for them. By the time the representatives could properly consult with their constituents about the matters at hand, it may be too late. In the age of modern communications however, this need to find a representative with sound judgment is not as vital. You can now reasonably consider other systems.

For example, instead of voting for a person, you can vote for a committee, which then makes all decisions and tells its representative how to vote. Instead of trusting some bright-faced newcomer, you could vote for the Republican Party itself. This is similar to the party system found in other countries, except you have the choice of voting for an individual if you choose. If a party or committee is elected, they can switch their representative at any time and for any reason. Voters will have to make sure to check out the bylaws of the committee before voting for it. Any group of people can form their own board and publish their own laws on how the board is elected and how much leeway it has in changing its mind in regard to its fundamental principles, and then have that board run for local office.

People have and deserve the right to vote for an individual who they trust to change his mind on fundamental issues or even party affiliation when the need arises. They shouldn't be forced to do so however. This system gives them the option. It is the best of both worlds.

I first posted this idea 7/7/2002.

Curious Cat, Jan 06 2004

What do you think of this idea or comment?
(You can change your vote at any time)

agree I agree no opinion No opinion disagree I disagree

Users who liked this idea also liked:

Fast Food Ordering (30 votes) Very strong
Better Page Layout (17 votes) Very strong
*Night Museums (13 votes) Very strong
Greatest scenes from bad movie (12 votes) Very strong
Top-Ten List (10 votes) Very strong
Haircut subscription (10 votes) Strong
News ticker during commercials (9 votes) Strong
User list (9 votes) Strong
Colored Salt (17 votes) Strong
Daytime license (9 votes) Strong

Other ideas in category (Government):

Comments from other members:

Add your comment

This adds an unnecessary, undemocratic extra step in the political process. I think machine politics has quite enough influence already.

eastriver, Jan 06 2004